Thursday, June 12, 2014

Race and Ethnicity - Readings 21, 22, and 23 (6th edition)


Race and Ethnicity - Readings 21, 22, and 23 (6th edition)
Suárez-Orozco, C. (forthcoming 2003). Formulating identity in a globalized world. In M. Suárez-Orozco and D. Qin-Hilliard (Eds.), Globalization: Culture & education in the new millennium. Berkeley, CA, University of California Press. Retrieved from http://jdsde.oxfordjournals.org (Also Reading #21, 6th edition)

Rodriguez, C. E. (2000). Latinos and the U.S. race structure. (pp. 221-228) Reading #24, 5th edition

McLeod, J. (2003). Everybody’s ethnic enigma. (pp. 245-246) Reading #27, 5th edition

            According to Suárez-Orozco (2003) in Formulating Identity in a Globalized World, 10% of the population in the US are immigrants.  In addition, nearly 80% of these are of color (p. 1, p. 12).  Creating an identity in a new country is a challenge on many levels, especially for second generation individuals.  From ethnic flight -identifying with the mainstream culture- to coethnic identity -being adversarial toward the dominant group- these individuals struggle with finding a way to find an identity. Suárez-Orozco (2003) regards developing a transcultural identity as the most adaptive solution.  Being bicultural and bilingual and at ease in multiple social contexts is part of being a global citizen.

            Immigrant students of color face some of the same challenges as non-immigrants: negative expectations by educators and a negative self-image can lead to lower performance.  The way others perceive someone affects how they see themselves.  This is known as the ‘social mirror’ and it doesn’t take long to damage self-esteem and set up self-fulfilling prophecies. This makes the struggle to find an identity even more challenging.

            Suárez-Orozco (2003) concludes this article by stating, “We must allow newcomers to retain a sense of pride in their cultures of origin while facilitating their entrance into the new milieu” (p. 20).  Educators are operative in helping immigrant students develop a transcultural, or even global, identity.

            In Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure, Rodriguez (2000) talks about the difference between race and ethnicity, especially in America.  Latinos can identify with particular national-origin groups and specific races while still maintaining a Latino connection.  These identities are fluid and change with context and over time.  Rodriguez (2000) confirms the “social constructedness of race” while also stating, “it can be deconstructed, but it cannot be dismissed” (p. 225).
           McLeod (2003) shares her experiences as an ambiguously ethnic person in Everybody’s Ethnic Enigma.  She talks about the level of rudeness when people demand to know her background and then dismiss her when it doesn’t match their expectations.  Do we have the right to question others? Should there be a spoken or unspoken rule that we must justify ourselves.  We would protest if we had to carry our official papers and present them on demand, as is the norm in some countries, but racial ambiguity is the exception, and anyone can be the police... Or that is the impression I get reading these articles.
            There is a thread of commonality between these three articles.  In each case, being white is the most acceptable position, and everything else is just shades of tan.  Or black.  If you aren’t white, then what are you?  The idea that everyone has to belong to a group or argue how they fit into more than one group is repeated over and over.  While McLeod looks like she could fit anywhere, she is rejected when she doesn’t give the expected answers.  Rodriguez talks about Latinos figuring out how to fit into many groups at once, and changing identities based on context. Suárez-Orozco examines the different ways of accepting or rejecting the mainstream identity, with being a part of more than one group at a time being the optimal solution.
            When I first read these articles, I was thinking that race and ethnicity isn't an something I need to consider.  I am in the dominant group, lily-white.  My students aren’t from immigrant families, and none of them are Latino.  Or are they and I just don’t know it?  Now I am wondering about this.  In addition, if you had asked me two weeks ago, I would have said that I am not from an immigrant family, but that isn’t true either.  My mother was not born a US citizen, and English was her 5th language.  She married an American, and my sisters and I were all born overseas.  But we were all naturalized citizens and English is my first language.  So, am I a second-generation immigrant?  Or half of one, because of my father?  I had to go back and read these articles again, thinking about these questions.  I am not bilingual, and while I have some elements of biculturalism, I think that I have identified with mainstream culture in many ways, at least on the surface.  Perhaps my ‘eccentricities’ are actually my home culture peeking through…
          I am learning through all of these readings in different areas that we are affected in some way by everything… thinking that I am (at least) in the dominant category of any division is a faulty assumption.  When I look deeper, there is an element of uncertainty in everything.  Has anyone else noticed this? 

Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Disability - readings 18, 19, and 20 (6th edition)


Oliver, M. (1990). Disability definitions: The politics of meaning. (pp. 176-178) Reading #21, 5th edition
Mundy, L. (2002). A world of their own. (pp. 185-191) Reading #23, 5th edition
Lane, H. (2005, Summer). Ethnicity, ethics, and the deaf-world. Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education 10(3), 291-310. doi:10.1093/deafed/eni030 (Also reading #20, 6th edition)
McCune, P. (2001). What do disabilities have to do with diversity? (pp. 179-185) Reading 22, 5th edition


In Disability Definitions: The Politics of Meaning, Oliver (1990) discusses the constructivist nature of disability.  The way we define it becomes the way we deal with it.  If disability is a tragedy or social oppression, then we will treat people with disabilities as victims.  In our modern society, people who are unwilling to work are frowned upon.  If they are unable to work due to a disability, it is a different matter.  For the sake of people with disabilities, as well as those tasked with providing services to them, it is important to change the language from victim-based to society-based.  As Oliver (1990) clarifies, rather than label groups as “the handicapped, the blind, the deaf” (p. 176), it is essential to see people as people first, and speak of them as such.  (The author of this article must not have realized this in 1990, as he continues to speak of ‘disabled people’ rather than ‘people with disabilities.’  We continue to grow and improve as a society.)  The main point that this article makes is that disability is not a personal problem, but a problem of society failing to offer equal access for all types of people.  Whether this is wheelchair accessible buildings, or real-time captioning in a classroom, failure to accommodate special needs amounts to discrimination.
Mundy (2002) and Lane (2005) write about the Deaf community.  In both articles, there is some discussion about whether deafness is a disability or a separate culture.  Lane (2005) clarifies the difference between deaf and Deaf.  Small-d deaf refers to people who “had conventional schooling and became deaf after acculturation to hearing society” (p. 291).  These people are considered, by themselves and others, to be hearing people with a disability, deafness. Capital-D Deaf refers to people who were born deaf and consider themselves to be a member of an ethnic minority known as Deaf-World. This is the basis of Lane’s (2005) article. She explains why members of Deaf-World are not disabled, but a minority group, and why this is a preferable designation.  In Mundy’s (2002) article, two members of this Deaf-World discuss why they want their child to be deaf like them, rather than hearing, for similar reasons.
Oliver is right when he says that the way we define something effects how we treat it.  In the case of deaf vs. Deaf, one is a disability that should be treated if possible, and the other is a culture unto itself that should be respected as any other diverse culture.  Again, it becomes a matter of self-identification, and there are some overlaps between the two groups, but respecting diversity means valuing how groups define themselves.
I find disability harder to talk about than race or gender. This diverse group includes people with physical, learning, and psychiatric disabilities.  Within those subcategories lies even more variation.  It’s not the same as race or gender, which seem almost simple by comparison.  I may not always understand the culture of a different race, but I am able to discuss it.  Perhaps it is because a disability could happen suddenly to me: a car accident could leave me unable to walk, or leave me with a traumatic brain injury. I think my unease comes the idea that I could suddenly find myself in this group.  I’m not going to suddenly wake up Black or male, so I can remain objective.
In What Do Disabilities Have to Do with Diversity?, McCune (2001) talks about being embarrassed when having difficulty understanding a student’s speech.  I remember a similar experience when I first started college in my early 20’s.  There was a young man who often hung out in the common room. He was in a wheelchair and I think he had Cerebral Palsy.  He started conversations with everyone who came in.  I was embarrassed because I didn’t always understand what he was saying, and he drooled.  In my callous youth, my solution was to ignore him and act as though he wasn’t there.  In hindsight, I missed out on getting to know someone who was friendly and cheerful and had a lot to say.  I hope that my response today would be different.

Monday, June 9, 2014

Sexual Orientation readings (5th edition) part 2


Sexual Orientation readings (5th edition) part 2
The three articles about sexual orientation in the 6th edition present sexual preference as a dichotomy: gay or straight.  Well, occasionally bisexual… They also neglect to discuss gender as a continuum, going on the assumption that men and women are more different than the same. Another article, in the 5th edition, but not in the 6th, presents a more varied discussion.
Archer, B. (2002). The end of gay (and the death of heterosexuality). In K. Rosenblum & T. Travis (Eds.), The meaning of difference: American constructions of race, sex and gender, social class, sexual orientation, and disability (pp. 167-175). New York: McGraw-Hill.
Archer (2002) presents his personal experiences with the fluidity of sexual preference and the problem with labels and categories.  He outlines how attitudes and self-identity have evolved over the past 25 years or so.  His story shows how accepting one label leads to discounting earlier or later experiences as not valid, and ends by welcoming unrestricted sexual choice back into the conversation.  Note that this is about choice, not about quantity!
In the same way that we talk about female as compared to male, black as compared to white, or disabled as compared to abled, the conversation about sexual identity is defined by the different, the nonheterosexual compared to the heterosexual. Archer (2002) makes the point that sexual identity is a fairly recent label.  Throughout history, people got married or joined the church, fell in love with the opposite sex or the same sex, acted on their feelings or not.  Our society has constructed the labels and so we self-identify. 
I’ve heard people say, “Well, I’m not gay, but I have a (sister, friend, cousin, fill in the blank) who is gay, and I’m okay with it.”  Is rejection easier if you ask someone out and they say, “Thanks, but I’m gay” instead of “Sorry, not interested in you”?  In each case, the line is drawn between us and them.  When Archer (2002) says that there is “the possibility of a sexual attraction that is neither primarily nor exclusively based in anatomy nor especially relevant to your sense of self” (p. 170), it strikes a chord.  This is not an issue of gender, race, class, or even religion.  When sex is no longer primarily for reproduction, and no longer confined to the sanctity of marriage, the potential for choice opens up.  I have always said that the stuff between the ears is more important than the stuff between the legs.  In the same way that one drop of blood shouldn’t define a person’s race, one sexual encounter or attraction shouldn’t define a person’s sexual preference.  If we can move towards “mixed-race” as a race option, then let’s move towards “whatever” as a sexual preference. 

Sunday, June 8, 2014

Sexual Orientation - Readings 15, 16, and 17, 6th edition, part 1


Sexual Orientation - Readings15, 16, and 17, 6th edition, part 1
 
Peplau and Garnets (2000) discuss women’s sexual orientation by comparing it to male models of sexuality.  They begin by emphasizing that non-heterosexual orientations are no longer considered mental illnesses, nor are they linked to poor psychological functioning. They also confirm that women’s sexual orientation is not related to gender stereotypes.  They conclude that women’s sexual orientation is based more on personal choice and social influence than on biological factors. Most studies in the past focused on male models of sexuality.  The female experience is different and therefore needs a different way of thinking. One point is that women’s sexuality is fluid and changeable.  Another important note is that love and intimacy are more important for women than for men.
In contrast, Lancaster (2003) discusses three studies focused on looking for a biological marker for male homosexuality.  In each case, he deconstructs a study and decries the results.  His final comment for this chapter is telling: “As a complex, meaningful, and motivated human activity, same-sex desire is simply not comparable to questions like eye color, hair color, or height” (p. 256).  His point is that male homosexuality is not a fault in the genes that can be traced, prevented, or corrected.
These articles offer a taste of how different groups use science to support their viewpoints.  If homosexuality is seen as a choice, those who feel it is bad will do their best to force change.  If homosexuality is genetic, then some people might be more accepting, as it isn’t anyone’s fault.  The fear is that if there is a marker for queerness, then there might be a cure as well.
In America, viewpoints are changing and becoming more open.  The military, with its “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy has come a long way from when I first enlisted.  Back then (30 years ago), even suspicion of gay activity was cause for interrogation and dishonorable discharge.  I had a number of friends who suffered through this experience, and I didn’t understand why these intelligent, motivated, patriotic people were considered too immoral to serve.  Now they are allowed to die for their country like everyone else, as long as they keep their private lives private. 
But this is really a discussion of essentialist and constructionist theories, as related to human sexuality.  Is homosexuality an essential part of a person’s makeup?  Or is it something that has been constructed by past events or current situations or even our interpretations?  Is it a normal expression of humanity or an abomination against God?  This topic gets people riled up almost as much as religion!  Personally, I don’t understand what the problem is.  We don’t need to ‘be fruitful and multiply,’ as our world population is growing just fine.  Allowing same-sex marriage doesn’t change the institution of marriage for anyone else.  And expressions of love and affection must surely be preferable to hate.
Reading #15, 6th edition – Lancaster, R. N. (2003). The biology of the homosexual. In The trouble with nature: Sex in science and popular culture (pp. 240-257). Berkeley: University of California Press. Retrieved from http://ark.cdlib.org/ark:/13030/kt367nc6r3/
Reading #18, 5th edition – Peplau, L. A. & Garnets, L. D. (2000). A new paradigm for understanding women's sexuality and sexual orientation. (pp. 158-166)
Reading #20, 5th edition – Rochlin, M. (1985). The heterosexual questionnaire. (p. 175)