Meaning
of Difference - Readings 38 and 40 (6th edition)
Wise, T. (2009). Between
Barack and a hard place. (Preface to book) (Also Reading #38, 6th edition)
Seidman, S. (2002). Beyond
the closet: The transformation of gay and lesbian life. (pp. 269-276,
Reading #33, 5th edition)
Wu, F. (2002). The model
minority: Asian American “success” as a race relations failure. (pp.
426-434, Reading #52, 5th edition)
England, P. (2010, April). The gender
revolution: Uneven and stalled. Gender
& Society 24(2), 149-166 DOI:
10.1177/0891243210361475 (Also Reading #40, 6th edition)
In the preface to his book, Between Barack and a hard place: Racism and
white denial in the age of Obama, Wise (2009) makes a case for the changing
nature of racism in America today.
Rather than seeing the election of President Obama as the end of racism,
defined as “an ideological belief in the racial or cultural superiority or
inferiority of certain people” (p. 15), he instead has concerns that a new form
of racism has arisen. In this
Racism 2.0, as Wise (2009) phrases it, there may now be a “model of acceptable
blackness” (p. 11) that all blacks must strive to meet. This is reminiscent of the ideas put
forth in an earlier reading, about acceptable homosexuality. Seidman (2002) says, “the normal gay is
expected to exhibit specific kinds of traits and behaviors” (p. 272). This has the effect of marginalizing
any homosexuals who do not fit into this small category. Now Wise (2009) is making the same
claim for blacks. If you fit
specific criteria, then you can be acceptable, even if still black, but all the
other blacks? Forget about it!
Wu (2002) contemplates what it means to be a
member of a ‘good’ minority in his article, The
Model Minority: Asian American “Success” as a Race Relations Failure. This type of racial stereotype can be
just as damaging as a negative stereotype for a number of different
reasons. First of all, it isn’t
true that Asian Americans, as a group of 10 million people, fit any particular
description. Secondly, the implications
of this being a ‘good’ minority is that any minority can be successful in America
if only they try as hard as the Asians.
Finally, claims that Asian Americans, as a group, are intelligent,
polite, hard working, family oriented, law abiding, and successfully
entrepreneurial leads to jealousy, retribution, and retaliation on the part of
other minorities as well as by the majority (p. 432). However you look at it, this is still racial stereotyping,
and as Wu (2002) says, “a stereotype confines its subjects” (p. 432).
In
The Gender Revolution: Uneven and Stalled, England (2010, April) discusses changes
in work for women and men. Her
premise is that while women have moved into “men’s” jobs, the same is not true
in reverse. In addition, it is mostly
true for middle class women, but not for working class women. She makes a number of claims for why
this is so, from the continued pay inequities of “men’s” and “women’s” work to
the options for upwards mobility within women’s jobs that are more available to
the working class than to the middle class. Another barrier to true integration
of jobs for men and women is a “belief in gender essentialism—the notion that
men and women are innately and fundamentally different in interests and skills”
(p. 150). While we have an
ideology of equal access to jobs for men and women, it doesn’t play out in
reality.
In
all of these articles, there is a common thread about how prejudice and
stereotyping are currently viewed.
The dominant status group (White, Anglo-Saxon, Protestant, male
heterosexual, also known as the straight WASP male) tries to persuade
themselves and others that we have become an enlightened and welcoming society,
open to any and all diversity.
See: we elected a black man for president! See: women can work any job they want! See: gay marriage is fine and some of
my best friends are gay! See: the
Asian Americans prove that anyone can get ahead in our great and wonderful
country! But in each case, there
is an underlying message: we (the straight WASP male) will acknowledge your
presence, and if you know your place and behave properly, then we will accept
you as being almost as good as us.
You can be Black, but don’t act too Black. It’s okay to be gay, but don’t shove it in my face by
holding hands with your spouse. If
you are female, we will let you work in our manly jobs, but we are going to pay
you less, because, well, you’re female.
And thank you to the Asians for proving that if anyone is living less
than the American Dream, it’s your own damn fault.
This
idea of having diverse identities as long as you don’t flaunt it comes up a lot
at school. I am supposed to teach
diversity, but the underlying message is that you should try to
assimilate. It’s okay that I am
Jewish, as long as I don’t talk about it, especially with the younger
students. Many people at school
wear cross necklaces, but I haven’t felt comfortable wearing the Star of David,
because then children may ask questions that take us into dangerous
territory.
I’m
not sure how diversity studies should be taught in my classroom. Our Social Studies is based on our community,
but mostly on community helpers, geography, weather, and history. I analyzed the main selection stories
in our reading program, and out of 30 stories, there is one contemporary Black
family, one Hispanic, and one Asian.
There are two more stories about Black families, one in contemporary
Africa, and one African fable.
There are also two more Asian stories, both fables, and one story in the
Amazon Rainforest. There are three
animal-based fables and ten informational texts. Most of the informational texts are generic, but two of them
had white women, and one had a black man.
Two more were about white men.
Overall, including 4 of the informational texts, there were 13 stories
about white families or individuals.
Oh yeah, there was one story about a deaf white man, although it was
technically historical fiction.
There are 3 leveled readers to go with each of the 30 main selections,
and while there is more diversity in these books, not every student reads every
book. Overall, I realize that just
following the program is definitely giving a distorted view to the
children. So this year, I started
teaching my third grade students about diversity around the world using the
book, If the World Were a Village. The book talks about where people live,
but doesn’t mention race. It
discusses languages spoken, as well as gender and age, but skips sexual
orientation. There was a page
about religion, but I passed it by, based on prior experience with offended and
vocal parents. There are a number
of pages that cover clean water, clean air, and food supplies, as well as
access to technology (cars, TV’s, computers). The children were very interested, and they were surprised
to find out how different the rest of the world is. There is a companion book, If America Were a Village that I will try to read with them next
year as well. How are other
teachers addressing diversity studies in their classrooms? I am especially interested to hear from
elementary teachers.