Monday, July 14, 2014

Final Reflection, Aims of Diversity, Summer 2014


Final Reflection, Aims of Diversity, Summer 2014
Halfway through this course, I became hyperaware of my own categories of difference.  I started wondering what other people were thinking of me.  Am I too white?  Is my hair too short? Do I dress funny?  Can they tell I’m poor?  Are they treating me differently because of my perceived (insert favorite status here)?
            Once you start thinking like that, you see preferential treatment-and its opposite-everywhere.  For example, I took my third grade class to the Shelburne Museum for our end-of-year trip.  We had so much fun!  They rolled down a steep hill, ran pell-mell through a railroad coach car, and asked questions about forging steel, printing newspapers, and weaving cloth.  They were eager, excited, and engaged.  It was fantastic!  We even went into the buildings with beautiful quilts, fragile glass, and “real” art, the type painted by bohemians with berets…  They loved the John Wyeth, and wondered what it must be like to fly above a tiny house.  It was the best field trip ever.
            It wasn’t until the next day, when I was reviewing our experience, did I realize that the docents and other staff weren’t really that friendly to us.  When we visited the printing shop, the woman barely answered our questions, and didn’t volunteer any additional information.  She didn’t even make eye contact with me.  Huh.  Seems like we got that in most places.  There were plenty of people watching us, keeping an eye on us, but not interacting with us.
            And in the places with the shiny antique furniture, and the precious oil paintings, and even onboard the Ticonderoga, the children were repeatedly questioned, “Who is your chaperone?  You aren’t supposed to be here without your leader,” even when I was standing a few feet away.  They didn’t look at the children and see the learners; they saw the untidy hair and the torn sneakers and the one kid trying to take pictures on an iPad with a cracked screen-the best he could do for technology since he comes from a backwoods burg.  They didn’t see that our kids were motivated and engaged, they just saw their poverty! 
            I try to imagine what type of visitors they usually get. Kids from families who take them to the museum once a month, for the cultural advantages, and because Mommy is on the Board.  Kids with neatly pressed shirts, shiny shoes, and a disdain for the docents.  They stroll through, barely glancing at the displays, stepping outside to wait for the car to pull up. (See my prejudice shining through?)
            So now I wonder.  Did I imagine all of this because I am suddenly self-conscious about the poverty in our school?  I know that this trip to Burlington may be the one and only time our students go to the Big City.  We are country hicks, gawkin’ at the fancy stuff, and unaware of expected museum behavior.  When they look at us, do they see their own prejudices?  Or have I become hypersensitive about my roots?  It’s one thing to recognize and discuss diversity in others, but harder to acknowledge it in myself without becoming defensive.
It has been interesting, stepping back and looking objectively at labels and categories, comparing dichotomies to continuums, but you can never clearly see something that you are a part of, no matter how objective you try to be.   Our thought patterns are socially constructed, and observer bias creeps in unexpectedly.  Ultimately, whether differences are innate or learned, it doesn’t matter by the time I greet my students.  The differences are there, with all of the exceptions and caveats.  My job as a teacher is to decide how best to meet the needs of each learner, regardless of any and all categories of (socially constructed or not) diversity. Students arrive with years of socialization in place.  Even the playschool children already recognize the categories.  I help them to see the similarities so that they will be open and accepting of everyone.  Every year I have a different group of children.  Every year I change my methods to adapt to the class.  Every year I learn something new.
I can’t change where my students come from, but I can change how they proceed from here.  As teachers, we aim to address more than the mechanics of math and reading.  Whether it is acknowledged or assessed, we also help children to learn about the global community and to broaden their viewpoints.  This is as important in small, monocultural, rural communities as it is in larger and more diverse areas.  But there is an inherent dilemma in this practice.  If we only echo the local culture’s ethos, then we fail to adequately address this area.  But if we stray too far from the community standards, then we face opposition from the families who are striving to pass on only their own particular perspectives.  I ran into this resistance when I allowed a discussion about war in the 5th grade social studies classroom.  They had so many perspectives, from “peace at all costs” to “it is our responsibility to defend our way of life.”  I discovered that the students are more open-minded than their parents, as they had no problem listening and discussing varying viewpoints.  When they went home and shared some of these new ideas, some parents complained that their children had learned something they didn’t want them to know: not everyone thinks the same way.  This has taught me that I need to take baby steps, not because the children can’t learn faster, but because their parents are resistant. 
There are three things that I will take away from this course.  The first is that being colorblind doesn’t make racial inequities go away.  Neither does ignoring gender, class, ability, or sexual preference.  I was hoping that if we just stopped making such a big deal about it, labeling, categorizing, surveying, and discussing it, then we would all be on an equal footing.  Now I see how that is the mindset of the dominant culture, and that it only masks the problems.  The second lesson is that no matter how open I think my mind is, my subconscious has been influenced by the messages of the media and society.  I took some of the Implicit Association Tests, and discovered that my prejudices are securely in place, whether I like it or not.  My next task is to ferret them out and hope that recognizing them is the first step in changing them.  Finally, after all is said and done, it is up to each of us individually to speak out, set examples, and work on improving our society, even if it is one person at a time.  As teachers, we have the additional responsibility to broaden the horizons of our students as well, even if we upset the parents to do it. This may be the biggest challenge of all!

Tuesday, July 8, 2014

Bridging Differences


Bridging Differences
Cogan, J. C. (2003). Influencing public policy. (pp. 476-485, Reading #58, 5th edition)

Johnson, A. G. (2001). What can we do? Becoming part of the solution. (pp. 485-491, Reading #59, 5th edition)

Kivel, P. (1996). Uprooting racism: How white people can work for racial justice. (pp. 503-508, Reading #62, 5th edition)

These three articles discuss ways that we can work toward a more fair and equitable society.  This is the capstone section to our book, as once we have identified the socially constructed groups in our culture, analyzed the ways that the dominant culture manipulates and controls the subordinate groups, and recognized our own complicity in perpetuating injustice and discrimination (no matter what where we fall on the continuum of group memberships), then we must either act or abdicate our humanity. 

Kivel (1996), in Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice sets out ways to be a “strong white ally” (p. 505).  Accepting that people of color are angry about racism is the first step.  This anger is well founded, and denying it or belittling it won’t make it go away.  Being willing to talk about racism with members of other groups is also important, as communication is a key to understanding and acceptance.  Speaking out whenever racism is encountered is another challenge.  People frequently tell jokes that make fun of other groups, and by not objecting, we are implicitly endorsing stereotypes and prejudice.  Working for racial justice means taking a stand against injustice.

I have been seeing some disturbingly prejudicial behavior when I visit my sister.  She had some bad encounters with the Lebanese teachers at her last school in Saudi Arabia, and now she keeps making disparaging remarks about all Lebanese people.  I don’t like how she is generalizing about a whole group based on her experiences with a few members.  She also asked someone if he was a Muslim because he was having goat for dinner.  I responded that eating chicken soup doesn’t make someone Jewish, but I could tell that the other person was as uncomfortable with my sister’s comment as I was.  It is hard to speak up, especially with family. 

In What Can We Do? Becoming Part of the Solution, Johnson (2001) addresses the reasons that some people are aware of the problems in our society, but hesitate to act.  One reason is that they are not aware of how social systems change and grow over time.  By thinking that our culture hasn’t changed in the past, it is easy to think that it won’t change in the future, and therefore nothing we do will make a difference.  A related reason is that it is frustrating to work towards change without seeing results.  In the same way that we encourage our students as they make small steps towards a goal, we also look for some sign that our efforts are not in vain.  Johnson argues that we must overcome these excuses and fight to “change patterns of exclusion, rejection, privilege, harassment, discrimination, and violence” (p. 485).  While some argue that we should carry signs and march in protest rallies, Johnson lets us know that we can also be effective role models by showing the choices possible in every situation.  Walk the walk, and others will follow.

This is true in all areas of our lives.  Especially as a teacher or a parent, we find that children will copy our actions faster than they will obey our words.  If our words and actions match, then the message will be twice as strong.  Let’s make sure that it is a positive message!

On a larger scale, there are ways to change the laws and policies of our government, and you don’t need to run for public office to do it.  While just passing a bill into law won’t change the world overnight (see Brown v. Board of Education), it is a step in the right direction.  Cogan (2003) discusses ways to advocate for improvements in our legal system in her article, Influencing Public Policy.  She describes the five groups that are involved in making federal policy and outlines their roles, explains the central characteristics of these policy makers, and gives concrete examples of memos, talking points, letters, and visits.  Although her focus is on LGBT issues and the federal government, this same information is useful when dealing with other issues of diversity or other levels of governance. 

The overall message of this section is that we cannot sit idly by and wait for the world to change.  If we see the problems, we must act to fix them.  This may be by getting involved in the legislative branch of our government, or by noticing and commenting on the prejudice and discrimination of others’ words or actions, or even just by acting fairly and ethically in our daily lives.  I feel comfortable with the last two, but I’m not ready to do the first!  Other than signing petitions when my activist neighbor brings them by, I will have to do my part to effect change through example.

Sunday, July 6, 2014

Popular Culture - Readings 45, 46, and 47 (6th edition)


Popular Culture - Readings 45, 46, and 47 (6th edition)

Kendell, D. (2005). Framing class: Media representations of wealth and poverty in America. (pp. 138-143, Reading #14, 5th edition)

Harris, C. I. & Carbado, D. W. (2007). Loot or find: Fact or frame? (pp. 250-259, Reading #29, 5th edition)

Rosenblum, K. E., & Travis, T. C. (2008), Framework essay: The meaning of difference (pp. 334-351).

Kendell (2005), in Framing Class: Media Representations of Wealth and Poverty in America, offers an overview of how the media in America affect our vision of society and perpetuate inequalities and classism. She claims, “By ignoring class or trivializing it, the media involve themselves in a social construction of reality that rewards the affluent and penalizes the working class and the poor” (p. 139).  The media, in this article generally referring to television and related audio-visual entertainment, use framing to not only show us what we expect to see, but also to shape our expectations through repeated exposure to formulaic situations.  Framing is similar to Jean Piaget’s schema theory, in which we process new information by either fitting it in with something we already understand, or are forced to change our views.  This works because we have an innate desire to categorize information in order to more efficiently process it.  When we are being entertained by the popular media, we prefer to think as little as possible, and framing helps us to do this.  As Kendell (2005) says, “Media frames constitute a mental shortcut (schema) that helps us formulate our thoughts” (p. 140).
I have noticed something similar on the Internet.  Advertising, newsfeeds, and other ‘automated’ filtering systems use prior knowledge of what we have looked at in the past to show us other things that may meet those same interests.  I think it was a reporter on NPR who conducted an experiment by setting up two different computers and user accounts to test how his search parameters affected what was offered back to him.  On one account, he used key words that might be found in left-leaning liberal sources.  On the other account, he went right, far right.  He then watched in amazement as everything from news stories to advertisements veered in two opposite directions.  Not only did some of the news stories vary, but the slant in which the same stories were written also differed.  Apparently the powers that be (advertisers?) have figured out that we don’t want to be challenged in our thinking.  Think how easy it would be to subtly influence our thinking just through the ‘news’ that we are offered…
If media is not just reflecting the social construction of reality, but creating it by changing our beliefs, we must wonder why.  What is the ultimate goal of television, newspapers, magazines, and other media?  One common view is that they are all ways of getting people to spend more money (consumerism).  In the same way that a flower is a plant’s advertisement for insects to come and pollinate it (to create more plants), media uses shows to get us to watch the commercials to buy more stuff so that advertisers will continue to pay more money to create more shows.  But while insects reap some benefit from the process (food, shelter), we only lose out, by going into debt to surround ourselves with things we don’t really need.  Another view is that television and other media are used to shape our views while keeping us distracted and divided.  Television is the opiate of the masses…
Add to this the fact that media is doing this by perpetuating if not actually creating more distinctions between groups.  This article talks only about class, but the same case could be made for gender (almost any sitcom), orientation (Queer Eye for the Straight Guy), and race [starting in the 1840’s with minstrel shows that “offered an ideology about slavery constructed by and in the interests of those with power” (Rosenblum & Travis, 2008, p. 349)].  This use of popular culture to affect and control the people is not new! (Segue into discussion of The Bible as an early example of media used to shape society… but maybe not today.)
In Loot or Find: Fact or Frame, Harris and Carbado (2007) examine framing and the media in the context of race.  Using examples drawn from the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, they show how the choice of images and the phrasing of descriptions reinforce prejudice.  They say, “the most relevant and dominant frame is colorblindness, or the belief that race is not a factor in how we make sense of the world” (p. 252, emphasis in the original).  This belief is widely held by the dominant white culture, as we repeatedly blame individual behavior or character weakness for the bad things that happen to black people, and even when events happen to contradict this belief, we still revert to it afterwards, as it best fits what we ‘know.’  In the same way that we want our entertainment to be easy and not thought-provoking, we don’t want to face up to the reality of the inequities in our society.  To recognize it and not act would be unfathomable, so we blind ourselves to it and sleep easy at night.   Fortunately, the next section of our book discusses the many ways that we can be activists, get involved, and overcome!
Overview of Media Frames (Kendell, 2005)
Frame
Ideology
Connotation
Consensus framing
Members of the upper class are like everyone else.
I could fit in with them because they are just like me.
Admiration framing
Upper class people are generous, caring individuals.
I want to be one of them because they are good people.
Emulation framing
People in all classes should reward themselves with a few of the perks of the wealthy.
I deserve to have the same good things as them because I am as good as them.
Price-tag framing
The worth of a person is measured by what he or she owns (wealth).
The more I have, the better I am as a person. I can show my value by showing my things.
Thematic framing
Poor and homeless people are “faceless” statistics, not real people.
These people aren’t like me because they aren’t real.
Episodic framing
Poor people have many problems, but it isn’t linked to larger societal problems.
It’s their own fault that they are poor, not mine.
Caricature framing
Poor people are different then everyone else, in a negative sense, and this is funny.
I can laugh at them because I am not one of them.
Middle-class values framing
The middle class is the value center and backbone of the nation.
If it weren’t for me, our nation would fall apart.


Monday, June 30, 2014

Law, Public Policy, and Economy - Readings 41, 42, and 44 (6th edition)


Law, Public Policy, and Economy - Readings 41, 42, and 44 (6th edition)

Thirteen key Supreme Court cases and the Civil War amendments. (n.d.). (pp. 383-410, Reading #49, 5th edition)

Carr, J. H. & Kutty, N. K. (2009). Segregation: The rising costs for America. Available on googlebooks. Also retrieved from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1435-5957.2009.00232.x/pdf   (Also Reading #42, 6th edition)

Nelson, C. A. (2007, October).  Lovin’ the man: Examining the legal nexus of irony, hypocrisy, and curiosity. Wisconsin Law Review 2, 543-583. Retrieved from http://hosted.law.wisc.edu/lawreview/issues/2007-2/nelson.pdf (Similar to Reading #44, 6th edition) [not able to access Pratt (1998), but this article is similar, and in fact references Pratt frequently]

According to Carr and Kutty (2009), the main reason that African Americans have a greater incidence of poverty and the accompanying woes is decades of discriminatory housing practices. They say, "Denial of access to housing is arguably the single most powerful tool to undermine and marginalized the upward mobility of people" (p. 1).   They make a strong case for this, discussing everything from reduced access to high quality education and health care to increases in racial profiling, crime rates, and environmental hazards (p. 17).  The fallout of this continued discrimination is that our economy suffers, and we all suffer. Carr and Kutty (2009) conclude, " Housing discrimination is counterproductive to the national interest" (p. 2).  This means that discrimination against one group affects all groups.  If you didn’t think it should change because it is wrong, do you think it should change to help all of us?

            The idea that the problems of one group are really the problems of all of us is repeated in the next article.  More than 50 years ago, a legally married couple was arrested because of laws against interracial marriage.  Nelson (2007), in Lovin’ The Man: Examining the Legal Nexus of Irony, Hypocrisy, and Curiosity, ponders the changes, and lack of changes, in the intervening years by discussing her own interracial marriage.  She points out that wherever they go as a couple, one of them doesn’t “belong,” and while they generally avoid direct confrontations, there are times when her husband’s white male privilege makes him insensitive to the slights and injustices that she endures. She says, “Race shadows us like a hungry dog, gnawing at us when all we want is to be left alone” (p. 581).  Her point is that although the laws have changed, the attitudes are slower to catch up.  I don’t want any laws telling me who I can love or marry, but even with the law on their side, interracial couples continue to face challenges from society.

            These articles make me angry!   So many cases of discrimination, and not just in the far past history, but continuing and ongoing even today… I read through the Thirteen Key Supreme Court Cases and the Civil War Amendments, and there were many more examples of the legal system lagging behind the needs of the people.  Well, what could you expect, when for most of our history, is has been old white men making the rules?  Over and over again, people protested the inequalities written into our laws, and in every case it took time and argument before change happened.    Does anyone else realize that the Equal Rights Amendment, first proposed in the early 70’s, still has not passed?  While some people-usually old white men-say we don’t need a law defending equal rights for women, the fact remains that women still earn less than men, aren’t represented proportionally in upper level management, and have to work twice as hard for twice as long to get ahead. 

            Okay, I get it.  Change comes slowly.  Individuals and groups first need to recognize the discrimination.  Then they need to protest it, and stand up for their rights.  Then enough of our society must agree to push for change so that the people who make the laws change their perspective.  And even after all of that, it is a constant struggle to make sure that the new laws are followed.  Finally, after decades, if not centuries, attitudes and behaviors change.  By then, most people have forgotten the original story, and history repeats itself, just with a different targeted group.  Oh America, when will you ever grow up?

Sunday, June 29, 2014

Video Blog - Disability Readings 33, 34, and 35 (6th edition)


Well, this took longer to upload than it did to record!  But it's here now, so maybe someone will watch it.

Meaning of Difference - Readings 38 and 40 (6th edition)


Meaning of Difference - Readings 38 and 40 (6th edition) 

Wise, T. (2009). Between Barack and a hard place. (Preface to book) (Also Reading #38, 6th edition)

Seidman, S. (2002).  Beyond the closet: The transformation of gay and lesbian life. (pp. 269-276, Reading #33, 5th edition)

Wu, F. (2002). The model minority: Asian American “success” as a race relations failure. (pp. 426-434, Reading #52, 5th edition)

England, P. (2010, April). The gender revolution: Uneven and stalled. Gender & Society 24(2), 149-166 DOI: 10.1177/0891243210361475 (Also Reading #40, 6th edition)

In the preface to his book, Between Barack and a hard place: Racism and white denial in the age of Obama, Wise (2009) makes a case for the changing nature of racism in America today.  Rather than seeing the election of President Obama as the end of racism, defined as “an ideological belief in the racial or cultural superiority or inferiority of certain people” (p. 15), he instead has concerns that a new form of racism has arisen.  In this Racism 2.0, as Wise (2009) phrases it, there may now be a “model of acceptable blackness” (p. 11) that all blacks must strive to meet.  This is reminiscent of the ideas put forth in an earlier reading, about acceptable homosexuality.  Seidman (2002) says, “the normal gay is expected to exhibit specific kinds of traits and behaviors” (p. 272).  This has the effect of marginalizing any homosexuals who do not fit into this small category.  Now Wise (2009) is making the same claim for blacks.  If you fit specific criteria, then you can be acceptable, even if still black, but all the other blacks? Forget about it!

Wu (2002) contemplates what it means to be a member of a ‘good’ minority in his article, The Model Minority: Asian American “Success” as a Race Relations Failure.  This type of racial stereotype can be just as damaging as a negative stereotype for a number of different reasons.  First of all, it isn’t true that Asian Americans, as a group of 10 million people, fit any particular description.  Secondly, the implications of this being a ‘good’ minority is that any minority can be successful in America if only they try as hard as the Asians.  Finally, claims that Asian Americans, as a group, are intelligent, polite, hard working, family oriented, law abiding, and successfully entrepreneurial leads to jealousy, retribution, and retaliation on the part of other minorities as well as by the majority (p. 432).  However you look at it, this is still racial stereotyping, and as Wu (2002) says, “a stereotype confines its subjects” (p. 432).

            In The Gender Revolution: Uneven and Stalled, England (2010, April) discusses changes in work for women and men.  Her premise is that while women have moved into “men’s” jobs, the same is not true in reverse.  In addition, it is mostly true for middle class women, but not for working class women.  She makes a number of claims for why this is so, from the continued pay inequities of “men’s” and “women’s” work to the options for upwards mobility within women’s jobs that are more available to the working class than to the middle class. Another barrier to true integration of jobs for men and women is a “belief in gender essentialism—the notion that men and women are innately and fundamentally different in interests and skills” (p. 150).  While we have an ideology of equal access to jobs for men and women, it doesn’t play out in reality.

            In all of these articles, there is a common thread about how prejudice and stereotyping are currently viewed.  The dominant status group (White, Anglo-Saxon, Protestant, male heterosexual, also known as the straight WASP male) tries to persuade themselves and others that we have become an enlightened and welcoming society, open to any and all diversity.  See: we elected a black man for president!  See: women can work any job they want!  See: gay marriage is fine and some of my best friends are gay!  See: the Asian Americans prove that anyone can get ahead in our great and wonderful country!  But in each case, there is an underlying message: we (the straight WASP male) will acknowledge your presence, and if you know your place and behave properly, then we will accept you as being almost as good as us.  You can be Black, but don’t act too Black.  It’s okay to be gay, but don’t shove it in my face by holding hands with your spouse.  If you are female, we will let you work in our manly jobs, but we are going to pay you less, because, well, you’re female.  And thank you to the Asians for proving that if anyone is living less than the American Dream, it’s your own damn fault.

            This idea of having diverse identities as long as you don’t flaunt it comes up a lot at school.  I am supposed to teach diversity, but the underlying message is that you should try to assimilate.  It’s okay that I am Jewish, as long as I don’t talk about it, especially with the younger students.  Many people at school wear cross necklaces, but I haven’t felt comfortable wearing the Star of David, because then children may ask questions that take us into dangerous territory. 

            I’m not sure how diversity studies should be taught in my classroom.  Our Social Studies is based on our community, but mostly on community helpers, geography, weather, and history.  I analyzed the main selection stories in our reading program, and out of 30 stories, there is one contemporary Black family, one Hispanic, and one Asian.  There are two more stories about Black families, one in contemporary Africa, and one African fable.  There are also two more Asian stories, both fables, and one story in the Amazon Rainforest.  There are three animal-based fables and ten informational texts.  Most of the informational texts are generic, but two of them had white women, and one had a black man.  Two more were about white men.  Overall, including 4 of the informational texts, there were 13 stories about white families or individuals.  Oh yeah, there was one story about a deaf white man, although it was technically historical fiction.  There are 3 leveled readers to go with each of the 30 main selections, and while there is more diversity in these books, not every student reads every book.  Overall, I realize that just following the program is definitely giving a distorted view to the children.  So this year, I started teaching my third grade students about diversity around the world using the book, If the World Were a Village.  The book talks about where people live, but doesn’t mention race.  It discusses languages spoken, as well as gender and age, but skips sexual orientation.  There was a page about religion, but I passed it by, based on prior experience with offended and vocal parents.  There are a number of pages that cover clean water, clean air, and food supplies, as well as access to technology (cars, TV’s, computers).  The children were very interested, and they were surprised to find out how different the rest of the world is.  There is a companion book, If America Were a Village that I will try to read with them next year as well.  How are other teachers addressing diversity studies in their classrooms?  I am especially interested to hear from elementary teachers.

Friday, June 27, 2014

Social Class – Reading #30 (6th edition)

Social Class – Reading #30 (6th edition)

Lareau, A., & Weininger, E. B (2008). Class and the transition to adulthood. http://books.google.com/books (Also Reading #30, 6th edition)

Fitzgerald, B. K. (2003). The opportunity for a college education: Real promise or hollow rhetoric? (pp. 306-312, Reading #39, 5th edition)

In Class and the Transition to Adulthood, Lareau and Weininger (2008) discuss the disparity between middle class, working class, and poor families when it comes time for adolescents to apply to college.  Students need to plan ahead to take the right courses in high school.  They need to figure out all of the different application deadlines and requirements, as well as the various essays.  Financial aid forms call for a whole different process, and students need to plan and take the SATs or ACTs.  Visiting campuses for an interview and maybe even staying overnight are also part of the college application process.  Having an adult to help and guide a student through this process can make the difference between success and failure in gaining entry to a college.  Middle class parents are more likely to understand the steps and be involved, while working class and poor families follow a more laissez-faire path. Lareau and Weininger (2008) describe this difference as a continuation of earlier child-rearing attitudes. Middle class parents “view it as their duty to actively foster the development of their children’s potential skills and talents,” also known as concerted cultivation, while working class and poor parents assume “children will grow and thrive spontaneously” (p. 123).  This is also called accomplishment of natural growth.

I thought that these description of interactions with children evoked Ruby Paine and the Culture of Poverty.  While Lareau and Weininger (2008) never came right out and said that poor parents aren’t as good as middle class parents, they noted some differences that could be construed as negative.  I want to read the Lareau’s original book, Unequal Childhoods (2003), and see how this relates to Ruby Paine’s work.

Even though I am working class, I feel good about my involvement with my daughter during high school and my ability to support her in her search for a college.  She took the right courses at the right times, although there was that AP class conflict her senior year.  (She could only take AP English if she dropped music, and music was her sanity.)  We visited campuses, and I read her entrance essays.  I supported her choices of colleges, and she was accepted into 3 of the 5 that she applied to.  We figured out the financial aid, and I understood that a higher-priced college also offered more grants to make it affordable.  What more could I have done?

Should I have been more of a helicopter parent once she was accepted and enrolled?  You have to know my daughter to understand why I wasn’t.  I tried to be helpful, but my daughter has always resisted my ‘interference.’  And I do mean always!  When she was 18 months old, if she was hurt, she would hide under the table and not let me touch her… So, I have learned to step back and let her make her own way, but it is painful to watch her struggle and know that if she would only take my advice things could have worked out differently.  For example, when she was failing a class in college because she was sick and couldn’t do the final assignment (to usher at a theatrical performance and then write a critique of it).  I told her to talk to the academic dean and figure out a way to make up the grade, but she wouldn’t do it.  Now she is a college dropout, after getting halfway through!  I am hopeful that she will figure out what she wants to do and then go back to college and finish.  Is this “failure to finish” a reflection of her working class background?  Were there other factors that played into this that I didn’t anticipate because of my social class?  It is hard to see it from the inside…

            In a related article in the 5th edition of our book, there is a discussion other struggles working class and poor students have when trying to get a higher education.  In The Opportunity for a College Education: Real Promise or Hollow Rhetoric? Fitzgerald (2003) emphasizes that being qualified for college is only the first half of the battle.  He states “financial need is the most significant barrier to enrollment” (p. 306), and then explains all of the ways our current system is stacked against people with limited funds.  I know from my personal experience as a student as well as the mother of a student just how unhelpful the grant and loan system can be.  I didn’t know that equity in my house would count against me, but two mortgages would be ignored.  And while I am fortunate that my second mortgage is running at 3.75% interest, I don’t understand why the loans my daughter took out are at twice that rate.  I also discovered that scholarships are not always a benefit: each time I received another acceptance letter (apparently I write really good essays), my financial aid would go down by the same-and sometimes greater-amount.  Wasted effort!
            I wonder how the Common Core’s focus on college (and career) readiness will play out. Assuming we reach that goal, what good will it do when students can’t pay for college?  Maybe online learning will be the solution, as without the brick-and-mortar expense, college should be more affordable.  But that would defeat the purpose of college as a class separator… If everybody has “stars on thars” then a diploma won’t be worth the sheepskin it’s printed on!