Wednesday, June 11, 2014

Disability - readings 18, 19, and 20 (6th edition)


Oliver, M. (1990). Disability definitions: The politics of meaning. (pp. 176-178) Reading #21, 5th edition
Mundy, L. (2002). A world of their own. (pp. 185-191) Reading #23, 5th edition
Lane, H. (2005, Summer). Ethnicity, ethics, and the deaf-world. Journal of Deaf Studies and Deaf Education 10(3), 291-310. doi:10.1093/deafed/eni030 (Also reading #20, 6th edition)
McCune, P. (2001). What do disabilities have to do with diversity? (pp. 179-185) Reading 22, 5th edition


In Disability Definitions: The Politics of Meaning, Oliver (1990) discusses the constructivist nature of disability.  The way we define it becomes the way we deal with it.  If disability is a tragedy or social oppression, then we will treat people with disabilities as victims.  In our modern society, people who are unwilling to work are frowned upon.  If they are unable to work due to a disability, it is a different matter.  For the sake of people with disabilities, as well as those tasked with providing services to them, it is important to change the language from victim-based to society-based.  As Oliver (1990) clarifies, rather than label groups as “the handicapped, the blind, the deaf” (p. 176), it is essential to see people as people first, and speak of them as such.  (The author of this article must not have realized this in 1990, as he continues to speak of ‘disabled people’ rather than ‘people with disabilities.’  We continue to grow and improve as a society.)  The main point that this article makes is that disability is not a personal problem, but a problem of society failing to offer equal access for all types of people.  Whether this is wheelchair accessible buildings, or real-time captioning in a classroom, failure to accommodate special needs amounts to discrimination.
Mundy (2002) and Lane (2005) write about the Deaf community.  In both articles, there is some discussion about whether deafness is a disability or a separate culture.  Lane (2005) clarifies the difference between deaf and Deaf.  Small-d deaf refers to people who “had conventional schooling and became deaf after acculturation to hearing society” (p. 291).  These people are considered, by themselves and others, to be hearing people with a disability, deafness. Capital-D Deaf refers to people who were born deaf and consider themselves to be a member of an ethnic minority known as Deaf-World. This is the basis of Lane’s (2005) article. She explains why members of Deaf-World are not disabled, but a minority group, and why this is a preferable designation.  In Mundy’s (2002) article, two members of this Deaf-World discuss why they want their child to be deaf like them, rather than hearing, for similar reasons.
Oliver is right when he says that the way we define something effects how we treat it.  In the case of deaf vs. Deaf, one is a disability that should be treated if possible, and the other is a culture unto itself that should be respected as any other diverse culture.  Again, it becomes a matter of self-identification, and there are some overlaps between the two groups, but respecting diversity means valuing how groups define themselves.
I find disability harder to talk about than race or gender. This diverse group includes people with physical, learning, and psychiatric disabilities.  Within those subcategories lies even more variation.  It’s not the same as race or gender, which seem almost simple by comparison.  I may not always understand the culture of a different race, but I am able to discuss it.  Perhaps it is because a disability could happen suddenly to me: a car accident could leave me unable to walk, or leave me with a traumatic brain injury. I think my unease comes the idea that I could suddenly find myself in this group.  I’m not going to suddenly wake up Black or male, so I can remain objective.
In What Do Disabilities Have to Do with Diversity?, McCune (2001) talks about being embarrassed when having difficulty understanding a student’s speech.  I remember a similar experience when I first started college in my early 20’s.  There was a young man who often hung out in the common room. He was in a wheelchair and I think he had Cerebral Palsy.  He started conversations with everyone who came in.  I was embarrassed because I didn’t always understand what he was saying, and he drooled.  In my callous youth, my solution was to ignore him and act as though he wasn’t there.  In hindsight, I missed out on getting to know someone who was friendly and cheerful and had a lot to say.  I hope that my response today would be different.

No comments:

Post a Comment