Sexual Orientation - Readings15, 16, and 17, 6th edition, part 1
Peplau and Garnets
(2000) discuss women’s sexual orientation by comparing it to male models of
sexuality. They begin by
emphasizing that non-heterosexual orientations are no longer considered mental
illnesses, nor are they linked to poor psychological functioning. They also
confirm that women’s sexual orientation is not related to gender
stereotypes. They conclude that
women’s sexual orientation is based more on personal choice and social
influence than on biological factors. Most studies in the past focused on male
models of sexuality. The female
experience is different and therefore needs a different way of thinking. One
point is that women’s sexuality is fluid and changeable. Another important note is that love and
intimacy are more important for women than for men.
In contrast, Lancaster
(2003) discusses three studies focused on looking for a biological marker for
male homosexuality. In each case,
he deconstructs a study and decries the results. His final comment for this chapter is telling: “As a
complex, meaningful, and motivated human activity, same-sex desire is simply
not comparable to questions like eye color, hair color, or height” (p. 256). His point is that male homosexuality is
not a fault in the genes that can be traced, prevented, or corrected.
These articles offer a
taste of how different groups use science to support their viewpoints. If homosexuality is seen as a choice,
those who feel it is bad will do their best to force change. If homosexuality is genetic, then some
people might be more accepting, as it isn’t anyone’s fault. The fear is that if there is a marker
for queerness, then there might be a cure as well.
In America, viewpoints
are changing and becoming more open.
The military, with its “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy has come a long
way from when I first enlisted.
Back then (30 years ago), even suspicion of gay activity was cause for
interrogation and dishonorable discharge.
I had a number of friends who suffered through this experience, and I
didn’t understand why these intelligent, motivated, patriotic people were
considered too immoral to serve.
Now they are allowed to die for their country like everyone else, as long
as they keep their private lives private.
But this is really a
discussion of essentialist and constructionist theories, as related to human
sexuality. Is homosexuality an
essential part of a person’s makeup?
Or is it something that has been constructed by past events or current
situations or even our interpretations? Is it a normal
expression of humanity or an abomination against God? This topic gets people riled up almost as much as religion! Personally, I don’t understand what the
problem is. We don’t need to ‘be
fruitful and multiply,’ as our world population is growing just fine. Allowing same-sex marriage doesn’t
change the institution of marriage for anyone else. And expressions of love and affection must surely be
preferable to hate.
Reading #15, 6th edition – Lancaster,
R. N. (2003). The biology of the homosexual. In The trouble with nature: Sex in science and popular culture (pp.
240-257). Berkeley: University of
California Press. Retrieved from http://ark.cdlib.org/ark:/13030/kt367nc6r3/
Reading
#18, 5th edition – Peplau, L. A. & Garnets, L. D. (2000). A new paradigm for understanding women's
sexuality and sexual orientation. (pp. 158-166)
Reading #20, 5th edition – Rochlin,
M. (1985). The heterosexual
questionnaire. (p. 175)
No comments:
Post a Comment