Kimmel, M. S. (2004). The Gendered Society, p. 117-126.
Reading #10
(5th edition) (#9 in 6th edition)
The first
question people ask when someone is having a baby is usually, “boy or
girl?” We look for clues to
identify these new persons, such as a preponderance of pink, and if the signals
are missing or mixed, we don’t know if the baby is cute or handsome.
Kimmel, in
The Gendered Society, asks two
questions. The first is, why is
gender differentiation practically global, and the second is, why is male
dominance equally global? He
answers the first question with the idea that gender differences are a social
construct, and it is the unequal situations that we assign to males and females
that cause femininities and masculinities, not the other way ’round. He offers examples ranging from women
in the workplace to single fathers ‘mothering’ their children. He says that “gender difference is the
chief outcome of gender inequality, because it is through the idea of
difference that inequality is legitimated” (p. 119).
The second
question is more difficult to answer.
Kimmel makes the point that ‘male’ is the invisible gender, much in the
same way that ‘white’ culture is the norm to which other cultures are compared. He then defines feminine behavior as
anything that does not fit the masculine ideal. He also discusses the same
concept mentioned in the framework essay, that differences within the groups
(male and female) are greater than the differences between the groups. However, he doesn’t address the
dominance issue clearly.
I find it
interesting that Kimmel didn’t mention matriarchal societies in history. My understanding is that when humans
were hunters and gatherers, females ran the show. They were the ones who magically reproduced, and it wasn’t
until humans started domesticating livestock that the role of the male became
apparent. But in the same way that
the victors write the history books, men have conveniently forgotten the past. Perhaps as reproductive technology
advances, and we can start an egg dividing and growing without the addition of
sperm, then women will once again take over the power.
I don’t
agree with Kimmel’s assertion that gender differences are only from gender
inequality. There are
biological differences, from the way the brain processes information to the
facts of reproduction. While I
agree that differences within the group are greater than differences between
the groups, there are still differences.
With my own daughter (my favorite test subject), I made a conscious
effort to raise her as gender-neutral as possible, short of refusing to
identify her as female. (Does anyone remember the story of Baby X?) I dressed her in greens and purples,
and bought a literal truckload of sand for the backyard. She loved it, and immediately took her
stuffed animals for rides on the Tonka truck backhoe. Her best friend at the age of two, having received an
incredible fire truck that had flashing lights and blaring sirens, lifted her
shirt and nursed her “wild child.”
Of course these are only two cases, and there are certainly examples of
children who don’t fit the gender stereotypes.
On the
other hand, it is true that different situations bring out different behaviors
in both men and women. Different cultures reinforce actions in men that we
consider feminine in the US.
Physical displays of affection between men is the first example that I
think of. Perhaps my daughter was affected by something other than a giant pile
of sand, and her friend was certainly mimicking her mother’s actions with her
new baby sister. In the same way
that ‘male’ and ‘white’ are the invisible categories, I think we see gender
differences as normal.
Claudia:
ReplyDeleteHow confident are you in this statement: "There are biological differences, from the way the brain processes information ... ". Do you mean that the brains of women and men operate in identifiably different ways?
Many Professional Development programs for teachers promote the idea that boys' and girls' brains operate differently, yet the evidence for this is weak. Wondering about your thoughts on this and the origin of those ideas.
djm
While I agree that some brain differences are a result of socialization - form following function - there are also studies that provide evidence for gender differences separate from that. I suppose the only way to truly separate nurture from nature in this case would be to raise a whole cadre of Baby X's.
ReplyDeleteBy the time I see the children (age 3), the differences I see are undoubtedly greater due to reinforcement. Girls are more verbal, and generally have better fine motor skills, while boys are stronger in gross motor and visual-spatial awareness. There are greater differences within the genders than between the genders, but I still see differences.
After a certain point, it is no longer a question of chicken or egg (nurture or nature). I need to engage boys and girls differently because, for whatever reasons, they learn differently. Generally speaking!
I found this article especially interesting:
Wood, J. L., Murko, V., & Nopoulos, P (2008). Ventral frontal cortex in children: morphology, social cognition and femininity/masculinity. SCAN 3,168–176. doi:10.1093/scan/nsn010
Abstract: “The ventral frontal cortex (VFC) has been shown to differ morphologically between sexes. Social cognition, which many studies demonstrate involves the VFC, also differs between sexes, with females being more adept than males.”
Also: "recent studies have shown that early in utero hormonal exposure interacting with expression of specific genes facilitates the development of elaborate social cognition and behavior systems (Adolphs 2001). Several genes located on the sex chromosomes are expressed to significantly different degrees in the prefrontal cortices of males and females (Vawter et al. 2004)."
Granted, I could probably find a study to back anything I claim, thanks to Google. Or better yet, I could design and carry out a study to support my hypothesis. The joys of data analysis and statistical manipulation, added to conscious or subconscious observer bias, choice of study subjects, phrasing of questions, and so many other variables that can be controlled, means that I could prove anything I want, although it might not be replicable. We see what we expect to see. I have even read meta-analyses manipulated by excluding many studies that didn’t support the hypothesis, although never blatantly.
ReplyDeleteIn addition, when discussing gender differences, it comes back to a definition of gender. Genetics? External hardware? Self-identification? Choosing the subjects based on different criteria will lead to different results. And it still circles back to our socially constructed ideas of male and female.
There are so many directions I could go here. On my morning walks, I think about all of the things I want to discuss, but by the time I get home and pour a cup of coffee, most of it has receded again. How about gender differences in animals? Male dogs lift a leg to urinate, while female dogs squat. I have known exceptions to this rule, but I believe it is an accurate statement in general. But how do we define male and female dogs? By external genitalia. Has anyone ever asked dogs whether they consider themselves male or female? Maybe that is what they are expressing when they pee.
Birds: Both male and female may sit on the eggs among some species, but I have never known a broody rooster. I have seen a rooster call chicks over to eat a bug or seed. I can anthropomorphize this as nurturing behavior. Other male birds of different species feed their young too: robins, penguins, etc.
Birds often mate for life, unlike many mammals. Humans have claimed monogamy, but based on records of infidelity and divorce, perhaps it isn’t our natural state. My daughter tells me about the many categories of relationships the younger generation recognizes, and polyamory is very popular. This, along with gender fluidity, and multiple labels for gender identity, sexual identity, and relationship status means that I use the wrong word or phrase about 90% of the time when I am talking with her. In addition, her generation has taken the word “queer” and co-opted it to cover almost anything that isn’t conventional or mainstream. Perhaps they are just doing what humanity has been doing for centuries, but without hiding or denigrating it. (But they have their prejudices and blind spots too.)