Reading #4 (5th
edition)
Garroutte (2003), Real Indians: Identity and the Survival of
Native Americans.
America
was home to millions of Native Americans long before the European settlers
arrived. Through a combination
of deliberate genocide and accidental infection, it is commonly accepted that
about 90% of these people were eliminated, allowing
the settlers to take over the country.
Through treaties and reparation, the United States government has
designated certain lands and benefits to citizens recognized as Indian. In many cases, there is a financial
advantage to being recognized as a member of a tribe. There are also drawbacks to being identified as Native
American, as prejudice and discrimination take their toll. Garroutte discusses the challenges of
certifying membership of a tribe, both from the perspective of the tribe and
also from that of the US government.
According
to Garroutte, different tribes require different degrees of Indian ancestry,
with a minimum of 25% being the most common. Some tribes look only for a single blood connection to
another tribal member, and in some cases, being raised by Indians suffices,
with no genetic connection at all.
The government, on the other hand, often requires a 25-50% connection,
although there are many inconsistencies in the legal definition aside from
this. The burden of proof appears
to lie on the individual wishing to be recognized as a Native American. This is in direct contrast to the
“one-drop rule” referenced by Davis (1991), which states that any amount of
genetic relationship to African Americans is enough to label a person as black,
no matter how minute that percent may be.
Most telling is the statement by Davis, that “merely being known as a
black in the community has usually been accepted by the courts as evidence of
black ancestry” even when the person in question could pass as white (p.
53). The difference is that the
advantages outweigh the disadvantages to being recognized as Native American,
but the opposite is true for African Americans.
Both
Garroutte and Davis discuss cases where identified members of a group either
pass as white or must defend their membership to the group itself. This emphasizes the cultural aspects of
group membership, as emotional and family ties are often more influential on
self-identity than genetic percentages.
As a 100%
White American (as far as I know), this doesn’t apply to me. On the other hand, my daughter has had
to think about this frequently.
She is one quarter Inuit, and with her dark hair, dark eyes, and
chiseled features, she looks more like her full-blood grandmother than anyone
else. She even inherited the
stocky build and square stance of the typical igloo-dweller. In an effort to connect her to her
absent father, I did my best to share my limited knowledge of her Inuit
background. Stories, artifacts,
and traditions were a part of her upbringing. To me, it is just a part of who she is, as much as being
Jewish is a part of her culture.
But when she started filling out forms for college, there was no option for
Jewish or mixed-race, only for Native American, so that is what she chose. This
matches the “hypo-descent rule” described by Davis, in that “racially mixed
persons are assigned the status of the subordinate group” (p. 52), although in
my daughter’s case, this is a self-chosen identity. She is not registered with her father’s tribe, and as he is
not listed on her birth certificate, I am not sure how she could ever prove her
membership as a Native American citizen.
Appearances aside, when my daughter went to college, she discovered that
culturally, she feels more Jewish than anything else, so while she still claims
her Native heritage when questioned, she claims that it has had neither a
positive nor negative effect on her experiences.
These
discussions of race highlight the constructed nature of the term. When being known as black in a community
makes someone black, but looking like an Eskimo doesn’t make someone an Eskimo,
then it becomes apparent that these categories are not empirically valid, but
created by social processes. I
keep coming back to the ideas discussed in the framework essay and explained by
Basow, that “differences within one group are usually greater than the
differences between the two groups” (p. 28). This makes the concept of only two
groups ridiculous in my mind.
Perhaps we should all just start checking off the “other” box when
questioned about race, rather than being forced to commit to one category. I want a bumper sticker that says
“Equal Rights for Others,” because in the end, that is probably the largest
group around!
References:
Banks (2009), Human Rights, Diversity, and Citizenship Education.
Davis (1991), Who Is Black? One Nation’s Definition.
Rosenblum and Travis (2008), Framework Essay - Essentialist and
Constructionist Orientations, pp. 3-6.
Claudia,
ReplyDeleteI love your reflection. Your story about your daughter brings us back to the question of race. What value or importance does it bring to our society, other than to put a label on people? Why does someone else get to decide what race you are? These articles really have me questioning the value of having someone check a box on what their race is. Are we not all really just one race, the human race? Our value and beliefs are what makes us unique. I like your idea of checking the box for other, or how about unknown? I really do not know what makes me white, other than my skin color. I have asked my parents about my heritage and they said, you’re a mixed of many things. How do I know I do not have black or native ancestry?
Claudia & Pam:
ReplyDeleteI am moved by the post and questions. They bring forth the complexities of this field of study.
Have you heard of genetic testing to determine one's heritage? Would you do it?
http://dna.ancestry.com/
djm
I would not do genetic testing, because it is just confirming the idea that race matters... I also am not being tested for the 'cancer gene' although it was recommended when my mother died of ovarian cancer. Ignorance is bliss, live each day, eat dessert first, etc.
ReplyDelete