Social Class – Reading #30 (6th edition)
Lareau, A., & Weininger, E. B (2008). Class and the transition to adulthood. http://books.google.com/books (Also Reading #30, 6th edition)
Fitzgerald, B. K. (2003). The
opportunity for a college education: Real promise or hollow rhetoric? (pp.
306-312, Reading #39, 5th edition)
In Class and the
Transition to Adulthood, Lareau
and Weininger (2008) discuss the disparity between middle class, working class,
and poor families when it comes time for adolescents to apply to college. Students need to plan ahead to take the
right courses in high school. They
need to figure out all of the different application deadlines and requirements,
as well as the various essays.
Financial aid forms call for a whole different process, and students
need to plan and take the SATs or ACTs.
Visiting campuses for an interview and maybe even staying overnight are
also part of the college application process. Having an adult to help and guide a student through this
process can make the difference between success and failure in gaining entry to
a college. Middle class parents
are more likely to understand the steps and be involved, while working class
and poor families follow a more laissez-faire path. Lareau and Weininger (2008)
describe this difference as a continuation of earlier child-rearing attitudes. Middle
class parents “view it as their duty to actively foster the development of
their children’s potential skills and talents,” also known as concerted cultivation, while working
class and poor parents assume “children will grow and thrive spontaneously” (p.
123). This is also called accomplishment of natural growth.
I thought that these description of interactions
with children evoked Ruby Paine and the Culture of Poverty. While Lareau and Weininger (2008) never
came right out and said that poor parents aren’t as good as middle class
parents, they noted some differences that could be construed as negative. I want to read the Lareau’s original
book, Unequal Childhoods (2003), and
see how this relates to Ruby Paine’s work.
Even though I am working class, I feel good
about my involvement with my daughter during high school and my ability to
support her in her search for a college. She took the right courses at the right times, although there
was that AP class conflict her senior year. (She could only take AP English if she dropped music, and music
was her sanity.) We visited
campuses, and I read her entrance essays.
I supported her choices of colleges, and she was accepted into 3 of the
5 that she applied to. We figured
out the financial aid, and I understood that a higher-priced college also
offered more grants to make it affordable. What more could I have done?
Should I have been more of a helicopter
parent once she was accepted and enrolled? You have to know my daughter to understand why I
wasn’t. I tried to be helpful, but
my daughter has always resisted my ‘interference.’ And I do mean always!
When she was 18 months old, if she was hurt, she would hide under the
table and not let me touch her… So, I have learned to step back and let her
make her own way, but it is painful to watch her struggle and know that if she
would only take my advice things could have worked out differently. For example, when she was failing a
class in college because she was sick and couldn’t do the final assignment (to
usher at a theatrical performance and then write a critique of it). I told her to talk to the academic dean
and figure out a way to make up the grade, but she wouldn’t do it. Now she is a college dropout, after
getting halfway through! I am
hopeful that she will figure out what she wants to do and then go back to
college and finish. Is this
“failure to finish” a reflection of her working class background? Were there other factors that played
into this that I didn’t anticipate because of my social class? It is hard to see it from the inside…
In
a related article in the 5th edition of our book, there is a
discussion other struggles working class and poor students have when trying to
get a higher education. In The Opportunity for a College Education:
Real Promise or Hollow Rhetoric? Fitzgerald (2003) emphasizes that being
qualified for college is only the first half of the battle. He states “financial need is the most
significant barrier to enrollment” (p. 306), and then explains all of the ways
our current system is stacked against people with limited funds. I know from my personal experience as a
student as well as the mother of a student just how unhelpful the grant and
loan system can be. I didn’t know
that equity in my house would count against me, but two mortgages would be
ignored. And while I am fortunate
that my second mortgage is running at 3.75% interest, I don’t understand why
the loans my daughter took out are at twice that rate. I also discovered that scholarships are
not always a benefit: each time I received another acceptance letter
(apparently I write really good essays), my financial aid would go down by the
same-and sometimes greater-amount.
Wasted effort!
I
wonder how the Common Core’s focus on college (and career) readiness will play
out. Assuming we reach that goal, what good will it do when students can’t pay
for college? Maybe online learning
will be the solution, as without the brick-and-mortar expense, college should
be more affordable. But that would
defeat the purpose of college as a class separator… If everybody has “stars on
thars” then a diploma won’t be worth the sheepskin it’s printed on!
No comments:
Post a Comment