Sexual
Orientation - Readings 27, 28, and 29 (6th edition)
Seidman,
S. (2002). Beyond the closet: The transformation of gay and lesbian life. (pp.
269-276, Reading #33, 5th edition)
Pascoe,
C. J. (2007). “Dude, you’re a fag?”
Adolescent male homophobia. Retrieved from smellslikecollege.com/PSYdocs/Dude.pdf (Also
Reading #28, 6th edition)
Rothblum,
E. D. (2000). Sexual orientation and sex
in women’s lives: Conceptual and methodological issues. (pp. 277-282,
Reading #34, 5th edition)
Beneke,
T. (1997). Proving Manhood. (pp.
263-268, Reading #31, 5th edition)
Pascoe (2007), in “Dude,
You’re a Fag?” Adolescent Male Homophobia, continues the discussion started by Beneke
(1997) in the last set of readings.
While the title leads me to think this is an article about sexual
orientation, it is really about definitions of masculinity and how males form
and maintain that identity. When
young men use the term ‘fag,’ which could be considered a homophobic slur, they
are making a commentary about masculinity, not sex. At one point Pascoe (2007) says, “becoming a fag has as much
to do with failing at the masculine tasks of competence, heterosexual prowess,
and strength or in any way revealing weakness or femininity as it does with a
sexual identity” (p. 306), and elsewhere clarifies the use in this instance as
“a generic insult for incompetence" (p. 309). In addition, there is a case to be made for
intersectionality, as race is also a factor in how the term is used and
interpreted. Pascoe (2007) states "African
American boys were much more likely to tease one another for being white than
for being a fag" (p. 311).
His conclusion is that “homophobic language and joking rituals makes
clear that it is not just homophobia, but a gendered and racialized homophobia”
(p. 312). In other words, it has
more to do with being white and being male than with being gay.
Seidman (2002), in Beyond the closet: The transformation of gay and lesbian life,
discusses the difference between a core identity, one that is the main focus of
everything you do, or a thread, which is only important during specified
times. Social pressures may
influence these, as the more you go against the status quo, the more of a core
identity something must be. For
example, during the 1950’s to 1980’s, a time of “heightened public homophobia”
(p. 270), homosexuals were either completely repressed, or being gay was the
heart of their identity. As
attitudes towards homosexuality have relaxed, the need to make sexual
orientation a core identity has also relaxed, allowing it to be merely one of
the many threads that make up a person.
This echoes back and forth, and as homosexuality is seen as just another
part of normal behaviors, then more people are comfortable with a more fluid
orientation. This is most evident
in the attitudes of young adults, as they give up labels of “straight” and
“gay” in favor of “queer.”
This parallels the distancing of certain
ethnic groups from the ‘bad’ label of black, moving toward the ‘good’ label of
white. Never quite making it, but
forming a third group, the almost-whites.
Now homosexuality, as long as it is normal sexuality, defined by Seidman
(2002) as “sex that is exclusively between adults, that conforms to dichotomous
gender norms that is private, tender, caring, genitally centered, and linked to
love, marriage, and monogamy” (p. 273), is moving closer to heterosexuality
(the dominant master status) by distancing from ‘abnormal’ sexuality: “sex
workers, libertines, sexually aggressive women, sexually active youth… commercial
sex, multiple-partner sex” (p. 274).
Not quite straight, but not quite as bad as queer… The downside is that anyone-straight or
gay-who is interested in something outside the box (of so-called normal
sexuality) is subject to stigma and censure. Why does increased acceptance for one group need to result
in decreased acceptance for another?
This doesn’t seem like a fair trade-off to me, either in race or orientation.
In Sexual
Orientation and Sex in Women’s Lives: Conceptual and Methodological Issues, Rothblum
(2000) continues the conversation by analyzing women’s sexual orientation and
activity along a continuum. When
sexuality is defined strictly in genital ways, then there is a whole dimension
of women’s sexuality that is missed.
Rothblum (2000) acknowledges, “There is increasing knowledge that even
the concept of gender itself is flexible, complex, and multidimensional… (and)
more research on women’s sexuality is necessary to learn about women’s ways of
being in sexual relationships” (p. 281).
As the identity of sexual orientation shifts from core to thread, the
concepts and labels fall away, leaving a multitude of ways to be.
I love seeing how times have changed from
when I was a young woman in my early 20’s. To be gay in 1980 meant being either butch or femme, and you
had to stick to your choice in the relationship. Furthermore, all of your friends should be out, and
everything you did was connected to this core identity. Acting too straight was akin to
‘passing’ and frowned upon. It was
all or nothing! Leaving the gay
lifestyle meant leaving all of your gay friends behind. Thirty years later, young women have
the opportunity to choose other core identities and yet still explore sexuality
as a thread. Watching my daughter
have various relationships without needing to label or categorize herself has
been interesting. She says that I
can’t understand what she is going through, but I say that she has no concept
of what my life was like either.
Ah, the generation gap! We
speak a different language because we come from different social climates… but
we can still communicate as long as we are open to new ideas!
No comments:
Post a Comment