Monday, June 30, 2014

Law, Public Policy, and Economy - Readings 41, 42, and 44 (6th edition)


Law, Public Policy, and Economy - Readings 41, 42, and 44 (6th edition)

Thirteen key Supreme Court cases and the Civil War amendments. (n.d.). (pp. 383-410, Reading #49, 5th edition)

Carr, J. H. & Kutty, N. K. (2009). Segregation: The rising costs for America. Available on googlebooks. Also retrieved from http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1435-5957.2009.00232.x/pdf   (Also Reading #42, 6th edition)

Nelson, C. A. (2007, October).  Lovin’ the man: Examining the legal nexus of irony, hypocrisy, and curiosity. Wisconsin Law Review 2, 543-583. Retrieved from http://hosted.law.wisc.edu/lawreview/issues/2007-2/nelson.pdf (Similar to Reading #44, 6th edition) [not able to access Pratt (1998), but this article is similar, and in fact references Pratt frequently]

According to Carr and Kutty (2009), the main reason that African Americans have a greater incidence of poverty and the accompanying woes is decades of discriminatory housing practices. They say, "Denial of access to housing is arguably the single most powerful tool to undermine and marginalized the upward mobility of people" (p. 1).   They make a strong case for this, discussing everything from reduced access to high quality education and health care to increases in racial profiling, crime rates, and environmental hazards (p. 17).  The fallout of this continued discrimination is that our economy suffers, and we all suffer. Carr and Kutty (2009) conclude, " Housing discrimination is counterproductive to the national interest" (p. 2).  This means that discrimination against one group affects all groups.  If you didn’t think it should change because it is wrong, do you think it should change to help all of us?

            The idea that the problems of one group are really the problems of all of us is repeated in the next article.  More than 50 years ago, a legally married couple was arrested because of laws against interracial marriage.  Nelson (2007), in Lovin’ The Man: Examining the Legal Nexus of Irony, Hypocrisy, and Curiosity, ponders the changes, and lack of changes, in the intervening years by discussing her own interracial marriage.  She points out that wherever they go as a couple, one of them doesn’t “belong,” and while they generally avoid direct confrontations, there are times when her husband’s white male privilege makes him insensitive to the slights and injustices that she endures. She says, “Race shadows us like a hungry dog, gnawing at us when all we want is to be left alone” (p. 581).  Her point is that although the laws have changed, the attitudes are slower to catch up.  I don’t want any laws telling me who I can love or marry, but even with the law on their side, interracial couples continue to face challenges from society.

            These articles make me angry!   So many cases of discrimination, and not just in the far past history, but continuing and ongoing even today… I read through the Thirteen Key Supreme Court Cases and the Civil War Amendments, and there were many more examples of the legal system lagging behind the needs of the people.  Well, what could you expect, when for most of our history, is has been old white men making the rules?  Over and over again, people protested the inequalities written into our laws, and in every case it took time and argument before change happened.    Does anyone else realize that the Equal Rights Amendment, first proposed in the early 70’s, still has not passed?  While some people-usually old white men-say we don’t need a law defending equal rights for women, the fact remains that women still earn less than men, aren’t represented proportionally in upper level management, and have to work twice as hard for twice as long to get ahead. 

            Okay, I get it.  Change comes slowly.  Individuals and groups first need to recognize the discrimination.  Then they need to protest it, and stand up for their rights.  Then enough of our society must agree to push for change so that the people who make the laws change their perspective.  And even after all of that, it is a constant struggle to make sure that the new laws are followed.  Finally, after decades, if not centuries, attitudes and behaviors change.  By then, most people have forgotten the original story, and history repeats itself, just with a different targeted group.  Oh America, when will you ever grow up?

1 comment:

  1. Claudia, how right you are in your thinking. History always repeats itself in some way or another.

    ReplyDelete