May 13, 2014
Democracy is Liberty and Equality in
Balance
We agree as
a society that children in the classroom should have equal access to quality
instruction and highly-qualified teachers, but we don’t always agree what that
should look like. Racial
segregation has given way to economic segregation, and when the dominant
religion is capitalism, with the idea that everyone can get ahead if they work
hard, our schools have stopped being equal. Add to that the documented relationship between poverty and
early language exposure, and some students start their schooling at a
disadvantage, even if they are in the same building with the same teachers. In
the end, some students are more equal than others (apologies to George Orwell).
We have
shared lots of fine talk about embracing diversity in the classroom and
teaching our students about the global community, but we must battle gale-force
winds to do so. I am at liberty to
teach morals and ethics and how to be in the world, as long as what I am
teaching matches up with the dominant culture’s view of what is ‘right’. This type of learning is difficult to
assess (and therefore not always recognized as important or part of what we
teach in school), and the parameters of what is tolerable are not clearly
delineated. In my practice, I have
often not known that I was overstepping the invisible line until I was rebuked. For example, it is acceptable to
discuss Greek mythology, and even mention pagan mythology, but the phrase
“Christian mythology” is a no-no.
Who knew? In a town that I
consider liberal, even by Vermont standards, there are still limits on what can
be addressed in the classroom.
Just
as Facebook and other social media are known for showing the reader top stories
based on previous interests, there is an unspoken message that we should only
teach children things that their parents agree with. To teach them something different may “undermine parental
authority,” to quote one particularly disgruntled parent. So even as we talk about valuing
individual children and their unique cultures and values, we are still being
gently coerced into keeping the group mainstream. Don’t rock the boat!
According to Biesta (2010)
It is rather easy to make sure that
uniqueness will not appear…This will
happen when we prevent our students from any encounter with otherness and
difference, any encounter that might interrupt their ‘normal’ ways of being and
might provoke a responsive and responsible response (p. 90).
Unfortunately, this is exactly what is
happening when parents find their comfort zone invaded. As the providers of a service
(learning), we must keep the customers (parents) satisfied. If this means tailoring our product to
best meet the expectations of the consumers, then all of our talk of democracy
in the public schools is just hot air.
One squeaky wheel and we cave in to demand. We try to show our support of differences by changing the
name of the holiday festivities from a Christmas party to a Winter party, but
down deep we are still avoiding difficult subjects in the name of keeping the
peace.
The
Critically Reflective Practitioner
As Socrates
(in Plato’s Apology) says, “the unexamined life is not worth living.” This matches Thompson and Thompson’s
view that we should be ever mindful of our practice, reflecting and growing
from each experience. As a
teacher, can I say that the unexamined lessons are not worth teaching? Not completely, as I can follow a
lesson plan from another teacher and the students may learn as intended. But in order to make changes, growing
as a person as well as a teacher, I should be metacognitive, constantly
reviewing, reflecting, adapting, and improving my practice. My students will be better served by
this habit, and I will be more rewarded as a teacher.
As
humans, many of us dislike change.
I find comfort in routine, and regular habits allow me to operate on
autopilot, letting my mind wander freely as I go about my daily schedule. But the opposite of change can be
stagnation, and I must make a conscious effort to avoid brain death. Taking further educational classes is
one way that I challenge myself, and this mindset of continual improvement
carries over into my teaching as well as my personal life. At the age of 40, I returned to
college. I earned my Associates
Degree, then my Bachelors Degree and K-6 teaching license. Apparently taking classes has become a
habit, because I now have an Early Childhood/Special Education endorsement, and
I am 4 classes away from my Masters Degree.
This
class (Critical Practitioner) and the one just prior (Advanced Studies In
Learning Theory) have brought me to a new realization. In the same way that my heart rate
adapted to a certain level of exercise, causing the need to ramp up intensity
to reach a target rate, my mind has adapted to the classes I was taking, and my
brain was operating without thought.
Last
semester, one of our readings was a criticism of Ruby Paine, but I pooh-poohed
it. After all, Bridges Out of Poverty was used in a
class that was part of my teacher training, with the full support and
endorsement of my professor at Johnson State College. I marked up my copy and embraced the strategies. I touted the book to my
colleagues. I dismissed this new
article as inflammatory, designed to start a discussion and garner attention
for the authors, but obviously not valid.
This semester, one of our books included three more articles against Ruby
Paine. I immediately turned to
them and started reading. After
all, I wouldn’t want to be considered closed-minded or opinionated. To my chagrin, I finally realized that
I had made the same error as so many others before me: I accepted the latest
fad as gospel without thinking it through myself. I failed to notice the inherent racism in the case studies.
I bought into Ruby Paine, hook, line, and sinker.
But
wait… Just because some pundits are anti-Paine, it doesn’t mean that there is
no value in what she says. My
personal experiences as a poor white woman as well as my experiences with
families who have endured generational poverty do match much of what Paine
says. Looking through Ruby-colored
glasses has allowed me to address the needs of the individual child more
effectively than before I read her book.
If nothing else, it has allowed me to recognize the huge influence our
families of origin have on our presentation to and perception of the world,
especially for a child who has seen so little else. I am no longer a mouthpiece for Ruby Paine, but I will not
throw out everything that she has taught me. And in the future, I will take new theories and consider
them more carefully for myself, rather than accepting the authorities’
viewpoints as gospel.
The
idea of ‘operating on autopilot’ came up again for me while reading my choice
book, Good Education in an Age of
Measurement, by Gert J. J. Biesta.
My principal has conducted whole-staff book study groups for many
years. We choose from the latest
evidence-based, best practices tomes, and month by month we discuss, analyze,
and implement various strategies and techniques from the books. As a new teacher, I have appreciated
the hands-on, results-driven aspect of this new learning. More experienced teachers have found it
refreshing to update and fine-tune their own practice. I believe that our studies have made us
all better teachers and helped our students to be more effective learners.
However Biesta (2010) says evidence-based education “limits the opportunities
for educational professionals to exert their judgment about what is
educationally desirable in particular situations” (p. 47). I suppose that would be true if we were
mindlessly applying whatever theory is put forth in each book, but that is not
how we use our learning. As professionals,
we take what is offered, and try different parts to see what works in our own
classrooms. As we come back
together to discuss our experiences, we find that we have each learned
something special. We haven’t
stopped using our professional judgment.
Instead, we have increased our background knowledge and honed our
techniques. The longer I teach,
the more I see the value in our mindset of continual improvement, not just for
the students, but for the staff as well.
This is also an example of being critical practitioners, as we reflect
not only individually and within our professional learning communities (PLCs),
but also as a whole staff.
In
hindsight, I applied the lessons of the book we studied my first year teaching
with less thought than I do now. I
was struggling with all of the other demands placed on a first-year teacher,
and drawing attention to my posted learning goals didn’t seem especially
important. But my principal said
to do it, and the book said to do it, so gosh darn it, I was gonna do it. I was on autopilot. Now, I see the difference in the
students’ learning when they are informed of the goal versus their learning
without awareness. It has become
second nature to mention the expected outcome of a lesson before, during,
after, and the next day. I didn’t
understand the value of this when I started doing it, but after 3 years of
practice, it makes sense. As with
the ideas of Paine, I need to take Biesta with a grain of salt as well. Some of what he makes sense, but my
experience tells me that he isn’t the end-all and be-all either. Even when I was neither reflective nor
critical, I followed best teaching practices, as defined by solid research, and
I was a better teacher for it.
In Chapter
3, Biesta once again strikes a chord, explaining how the new, managerial
definition of accountability, the ability to present auditable accounts, is in
conflict with the moral definition of accountability, responsibility for
something. I endeavor to act on
the second definition, but I know that there have been times where I threw up
my hands in despair and said, “Well, at least my paperwork is in order.” I am frustrated that I have not been
able to adequately meet the needs of specific students, and rather than be able
to admit this and ask for help, I was encouraged instead to present my
completed charts and tables showing what percent of students met which
artificial goals that had been set – by me, no less – in order to be
achievable. Wait, what? I set goals that I knew I could
successfully meet or justify not meeting, and that was the basis of my
choice. “Success” is
measured by my ability to forecast the results of data analysis and manipulate
the statistics, rather than my students’ development as educated citizens,
ready to join our society. Look,
Ma, I’m a success! Of course, now
that I recognize and acknowledge this non-productive circle of goal setting and
success mongering, can I in good conscience continue to do this? Or must I now speak up in meetings and
protest the requirement? I think I
already know the response from my principal: If the goals I have been setting
are not helpful, then what am I going to do about it? I need to have an answer ready before I bring it up. I need to set goals that will address
my responsibility to my students’ learning, and then work towards those goals. Darn. I need to reflect critically, finding a way to meet the
expectation of accountability while still improving student learning.
The question
that keeps coming up, in class, in discussion with peers, in the readings, is
what can we do to change this system that is inherently flawed? I became a public school teacher, not
because I was inspired by everything I thought it stood for, but because I
thought I could most effectively elicit change from within. Now I find that I am struggling to keep
up with the mountains of ‘accountability’ paperwork, and my energy to protest
has been sapped. I still believe
that change is possible, but perhaps my role is now to pass the torch of
dissent to the next generation. I
haven’t given up the fight, but I’m not prepared to lead the revolution.
Instead, let me educate the next generation so that they may be the new
leaders. I will just keep planting
tiny seeds in those little fertile minds and hope that no one catches on to me…
And yes,
this reflection is filled with alliteration, figurative language, and the worst
mixed metaphors possible. It had
to come out somewhere!