Bridging
Differences
Cogan, J. C. (2003). Influencing
public policy. (pp. 476-485, Reading #58, 5th edition)
Johnson, A. G. (2001). What
can we do? Becoming part of the solution. (pp. 485-491, Reading #59, 5th
edition)
Kivel, P. (1996). Uprooting
racism: How white people can work for racial justice. (pp. 503-508, Reading
#62, 5th edition)
These three articles discuss ways that we can
work toward a more fair and equitable society. This is the capstone section to our book, as once we have
identified the socially constructed groups in our culture, analyzed the ways
that the dominant culture manipulates and controls the subordinate groups, and
recognized our own complicity in perpetuating injustice and discrimination (no
matter what where we fall on the continuum of group memberships), then we must
either act or abdicate our humanity.
Kivel (1996), in Uprooting Racism: How White People Can Work for Racial Justice sets
out ways to be a “strong white ally” (p. 505). Accepting that people of color are angry about racism is the
first step. This anger is well
founded, and denying it or belittling it won’t make it go away. Being willing to talk about racism with
members of other groups is also important, as communication is a key to
understanding and acceptance.
Speaking out whenever racism is encountered is another challenge. People frequently tell jokes that make
fun of other groups, and by not objecting, we are implicitly endorsing
stereotypes and prejudice. Working
for racial justice means taking a stand against injustice.
I have been seeing some disturbingly
prejudicial behavior when I visit my sister. She had some bad encounters with the Lebanese teachers at
her last school in Saudi Arabia, and now she keeps making disparaging remarks
about all Lebanese people. I don’t
like how she is generalizing about a whole group based on her experiences with
a few members. She also asked
someone if he was a Muslim because he was having goat for dinner. I responded that eating chicken soup
doesn’t make someone Jewish, but I could tell that the other person was as
uncomfortable with my sister’s comment as I was. It is hard to speak up, especially with family.
In What
Can We Do? Becoming Part of the Solution, Johnson (2001) addresses the
reasons that some people are aware of the problems in our society, but hesitate
to act. One reason is that they
are not aware of how social systems change and grow over time. By thinking that our culture hasn’t
changed in the past, it is easy to think that it won’t change in the future,
and therefore nothing we do will make a difference. A related reason is that it is frustrating to work towards
change without seeing results. In
the same way that we encourage our students as they make small steps towards a
goal, we also look for some sign that our efforts are not in vain. Johnson argues that we must overcome
these excuses and fight to “change patterns of exclusion, rejection, privilege,
harassment, discrimination, and violence” (p. 485). While some argue that we should carry signs and march in
protest rallies, Johnson lets us know that we can also be effective role models
by showing the choices possible in every situation. Walk the walk, and others will follow.
This is true in all areas of our lives. Especially as a teacher or a parent, we
find that children will copy our actions faster than they will obey our
words. If our words and actions
match, then the message will be twice as strong. Let’s make sure that it is a positive message!
On a larger scale, there are ways to change
the laws and policies of our government, and you don’t need to run for public
office to do it. While just
passing a bill into law won’t change the world overnight (see Brown v. Board of Education), it is a
step in the right direction. Cogan
(2003) discusses ways to advocate for improvements in our legal system in her
article, Influencing Public Policy. She describes the five groups that are
involved in making federal policy and outlines their roles, explains the
central characteristics of these policy makers, and gives concrete examples of
memos, talking points, letters, and visits. Although her focus is on LGBT issues and the federal
government, this same information is useful when dealing with other issues of
diversity or other levels of governance.
The overall message of this section is that
we cannot sit idly by and wait for the world to change. If we see the problems, we must act to
fix them. This may be by getting
involved in the legislative branch of our government, or by noticing and
commenting on the prejudice and discrimination of others’ words or actions, or
even just by acting fairly and ethically in our daily lives. I feel comfortable with the last two,
but I’m not ready to do the first!
Other than signing petitions when my activist neighbor brings them by, I
will have to do my part to effect change through example.