Sex and Gender - Readings 24, 25, and 26 (6th edition)
Collins,
P. H. (1998). It’s all in the family:
Intersections of gender, race, and nation. (pp. 352-360, Reading #43, 5th
edition)
Beneke,
T. (1997). Proving Manhood. (pp.
263-268, Reading #31, 5th edition)
Hamilton,
L. & Armstrong, E. A. (2009, October). Gendered sexuality in young
adulthood: Double binds and flawed options. Gender
& Society 23(5), 589-616. doi:10.1177/0891243209345829 (Also reading
#26, 6th edition)
In the article, It’s All in the Family: Intersections of Gender, Race, and Nation,
Collins (1998) puts forth the view that the family unit is the primary source
of constructed concepts of gender, race, and nation. By analyzing various aspects of the “imagined traditional
family ideal” (p. 352), she shows how categories overlap and build upon each
other. In each case, there are
clear connections between society in general and families in particular. She discusses “the power of family as
ideological construction and principle of social organization” (p. 359), and
she goes on to show how political parties use this power to put forth and
perpetuate their own agendas.
If we accept Collins’ (1998) definition of
intersectionality as the way gender, race, class, and nation mutually construct
one another, and family values as a prime example of how this happens (pp.
352-353), then the other two articles in this section make more sense. Beneke (1997) and Hamilton and Armstrong
(2009) discuss the socially constructed concepts of masculinity and femininity
in current American culture. In
both articles, there is an underlying current of family-related social
values. The ways that men and
women are expected to behave is learned first in the home, and then reinforced
in society.
Beneke (1997) uses examples from twentieth
century literature to show that we have an accepted view of masculinity that
men must constantly and compulsively prove, or risk being labeled as less than
a man. These stressors range from
“that which would hurt anyone… that which poses a psychological danger… (and)
women” (p. 263). In illustration
after illustration, Beneke (1997) shows that men battle, swear, bully,
dominate, and constantly subject themselves to stress in order to prove to
themselves and those around that they are masculine. The question that he does not address is the original source
of these masculine ideals. Is this
something that exists in the make-up of a male? Or has it been constructed by society and reinforced by home
experiences? I have heard that the
way to predict how a man will treat his wife is to watch how his father treats
his mother…
On the other hand, Hamilton and Armstrong
(2009) focus on women and sex, and specifically casual sexual activity on
college campuses. They “argue
that gender and class intersect in the sexual arena, as these structures both
rely on beliefs about how and with whom individuals should be intimate” (p.
593). Like the first article, this
is from an intersectionality viewpoint.
Their conclusions examine how casual sex supports upper class women in
their college years by allowing sex “for purely sexual purposes” (p. 606),
without commitment to a relationship. The same behaviors are not beneficial for lower class
women, who, according to Hamilton and Armstrong (2009), “experienced the hookup culture as
foreign in ways that made it difficult to persist at the university” (p. 606).
In both cases however, there is a clear double standard between the sexes, as
women risk being labeled negatively for the same behaviors that make men more
manly, as Beneke (1997) might say.
I’m not sure I agree with the conclusions of
this last article. The behaviors
described are accurate as far as I can tell, but I believe that the authors are
confusing cause and effect. While
the original sample appears to be random (a single floor of a dormitory), the
choice of an all-white, predominantly heterosexual group, at a college with
sororities, in an un-named region of the US, creates a very limited view of
young women’s sexuality. While the
authors claim that the goal “is not to generalize from the experiences of our
participants but rather to bring an interactional and intersectional approach
to college sexuality” (p. 597), I had to read the article repeatedly to get
beyond the generalizations that they were making. If they wanted to make a case for the benefits of an
intersectional approach, they were successful. But if they were trying to avoid making generalizations,
they failed.
Why did this article bother me so much? I have been thinking about this for a
few days now. I had a daughter who
was in a similar situation until recently, living in a dorm at college. But the circumstances were quite
different. She was attending a
small, racially diverse, all-women’s college, with a large gay population. Now, I can’t speak to the expectations
and experiences of the more privileged members of her peer group, but I think I
can address the background of the less privileged women. Hamilton and Armstrong’s
(2009) statement that underprivileged women “experienced the hookup culture as
foreign in ways that made it difficult to persist at the university” (p. 606)
really sticks in my craw.
Seriously? Do they think
that hookups aren’t happening in the working class culture? With or without the “slut” label (which
I think is also less common than the authors portray), young women are hooking
up in my (lower class) hometown with greater frequency all the time. I know this because it isn’t a
secret. The students talk about it
openly, as though it is nothing more than a handshake. This is not a foreign culture to them,
and I doubt that it is the reason it is “difficult to persist at the
university.” That certainly isn’t
the reason that my daughter dropped out of college! I think that Hamilton and Armstrong should find another
intersection to analyze, perhaps that of sex and religion. Where is this college that has racially
segregated housing? I can only
imagine that it is in the Deep South, which is also known for its extremely
conservative religious beliefs.
But I do agree that analyzing trends and
behaviors by relating more than one category makes sense. It is where systems intersect that we
are most likely to recognize privilege or stigma, as it is magnified at these
points. Trying to understand the
effects of poverty without considering race, or sexual preference without
thinking about gender identification is like trying to describe lasagna by its
separate layers and not considering how the flavors marry. The 5th edition of our book
has a subsection of six articles dedicated to intersectionality, and while two
of the articles are also in the 6th edition, they have been moved to
different subsections. I haven’t
decided yet if this means that intersectionality is now embedded in the book,
or if it is an idea that has peaked and passed.