Race and Ethnicity - Readings 21, 22, and 23 (6th edition)
Suárez-Orozco, C.
(forthcoming 2003). Formulating identity in a globalized world. In M. Suárez-Orozco and D.
Qin-Hilliard (Eds.), Globalization:
Culture & education in the new millennium. Berkeley, CA, University of California Press. Retrieved from
http://jdsde.oxfordjournals.org (Also Reading #21, 6th edition)
Rodriguez, C. E. (2000). Latinos and the U.S. race structure. (pp. 221-228) Reading #24, 5th
edition
McLeod, J. (2003). Everybody’s ethnic enigma. (pp. 245-246) Reading #27, 5th
edition
According
to Suárez-Orozco (2003) in Formulating
Identity in a Globalized World, 10% of the population
in the US are immigrants. In
addition, nearly 80% of these are of color (p. 1, p. 12). Creating an identity in a new country
is a challenge on many levels, especially for second generation
individuals. From ethnic flight -identifying
with the mainstream culture- to coethnic identity -being adversarial toward the
dominant group- these individuals struggle with finding a way to find an
identity. Suárez-Orozco (2003) regards developing a transcultural identity as
the most adaptive solution. Being
bicultural and bilingual and at ease in multiple social contexts is part of
being a global citizen.
Immigrant
students of color face some of the same challenges as non-immigrants: negative
expectations by educators and a negative self-image can lead to lower
performance. The way others
perceive someone affects how they see themselves. This is known as the ‘social mirror’ and it doesn’t take
long to damage self-esteem and set up self-fulfilling prophecies. This makes
the struggle to find an identity even more challenging.
Suárez-Orozco (2003) concludes this article by stating, “We must allow newcomers to retain a sense of pride in
their cultures of origin while facilitating their entrance into the new milieu”
(p. 20). Educators are operative
in helping immigrant students develop a transcultural, or even global,
identity.
In
Latinos and the U.S. Race Structure,
Rodriguez (2000) talks about the difference between race and ethnicity,
especially in America. Latinos can
identify with particular national-origin groups and specific races while still
maintaining a Latino connection.
These identities are fluid and change with context and over time. Rodriguez (2000) confirms the “social
constructedness of race” while also stating, “it can be deconstructed, but it
cannot be dismissed” (p. 225).
McLeod
(2003) shares her experiences as an ambiguously ethnic person in Everybody’s Ethnic Enigma. She talks about the level of rudeness
when people demand to know her background and then dismiss her when it doesn’t
match their expectations. Do we have the right to question others? Should there be a spoken or unspoken rule that we must justify ourselves. We would protest if we had to carry our official papers and present them on demand, as is the norm in some countries, but racial ambiguity is the exception, and anyone can be the police... Or that is the impression I get reading these articles.
There
is a thread of commonality between these three articles. In each case, being white is the most
acceptable position, and everything else is just shades of tan. Or black. If you aren’t white, then what are you? The idea that everyone has to belong to
a group or argue how they fit into more than one group is repeated over and
over. While McLeod looks like she
could fit anywhere, she is rejected when she doesn’t give the expected
answers. Rodriguez talks about
Latinos figuring out how to fit into many groups at once, and changing identities
based on context. Suárez-Orozco examines the
different ways of accepting or rejecting the mainstream identity, with being a
part of more than one group at a time being the optimal solution.
When
I first read these articles, I was thinking that race and ethnicity isn't an something I need to consider. I am in the dominant group, lily-white. My students aren’t from immigrant
families, and none of them are Latino.
Or are they and I just don’t know it? Now I am wondering about this. In addition, if you had asked me two weeks ago, I would have
said that I am not from an immigrant family, but that isn’t true either. My mother was not born a US citizen,
and English was her 5th language. She married an American, and my sisters and I were
all born overseas. But we were all naturalized citizens and English is my first language. So, am I a second-generation immigrant? Or half of one, because of my
father? I had to go back and read
these articles again, thinking about these questions. I am not bilingual, and while I have some elements of
biculturalism, I think that I have identified with mainstream culture in many
ways, at least on the surface.
Perhaps my ‘eccentricities’ are actually my home culture peeking
through…
I
am learning through all of these readings in different areas that we are
affected in some way by everything… thinking that I am (at least) in the
dominant category of any division is a faulty assumption. When I look deeper, there is an element
of uncertainty in everything. Has
anyone else noticed this?