Sexual Orientation readings (5th
edition) part 2
The three articles
about sexual orientation in the 6th edition present sexual
preference as a dichotomy: gay or straight. Well, occasionally bisexual… They also neglect to discuss gender
as a continuum, going on the assumption that men and women are more different
than the same. Another article, in the 5th edition, but not in the 6th,
presents a more varied discussion.
Archer, B. (2002). The
end of gay (and the death of heterosexuality). In K. Rosenblum & T. Travis
(Eds.), The meaning of difference:
American constructions of race, sex and gender, social class, sexual
orientation, and disability (pp. 167-175). New York: McGraw-Hill.
Archer (2002) presents
his personal experiences with the fluidity of sexual preference and the problem
with labels and categories. He
outlines how attitudes and self-identity have evolved over the past 25 years or
so. His story shows how accepting
one label leads to discounting earlier or later experiences as not valid, and
ends by welcoming unrestricted sexual choice back into the conversation. Note that this is about choice, not
about quantity!
In the same way that
we talk about female as compared to male, black as compared to white, or disabled
as compared to abled, the conversation about sexual identity is defined by the
different, the nonheterosexual compared to the heterosexual. Archer (2002)
makes the point that sexual identity is a fairly recent label. Throughout history, people got married
or joined the church, fell in love with the opposite sex or the same sex, acted
on their feelings or not. Our
society has constructed the labels and so we self-identify.
I’ve heard people say,
“Well, I’m not gay, but I have a (sister, friend, cousin, fill in the blank)
who is gay, and I’m okay with it.”
Is rejection easier if you ask someone out and they say, “Thanks, but
I’m gay” instead of “Sorry, not interested in you”? In each case, the line is drawn between us and them. When Archer (2002) says that there is
“the possibility of a sexual attraction that is neither primarily nor
exclusively based in anatomy nor especially relevant to your sense of self” (p.
170), it strikes a chord. This is
not an issue of gender, race, class, or even religion. When sex is no longer primarily for
reproduction, and no longer confined to the sanctity of marriage, the potential
for choice opens up. I have always
said that the stuff between the ears is more important than the stuff between
the legs. In the same way that one
drop of blood shouldn’t define a person’s race, one sexual encounter or
attraction shouldn’t define a person’s sexual preference. If we can move towards “mixed-race” as
a race option, then let’s move towards “whatever” as a sexual preference.