My first instinct when asked
whether humans are innately good or evil was to ask for a definition of good
and evil. After all, what is
defined as decent by one society may be disparaged by another. I believe that the underlying
motivation for all humans, as well as for all living creatures, is to survive
long enough to pass on genetic material to the next generation. If that means doing whatever is necessary
to keep my food and shelter, then that is what I will do.
As humans, we have evolved into a
cooperative society, capable of delaying gratification. We have learned to put aside individual
desires in order to work toward the common good. This doesn’t require 100% participation, but a sizable majority
is necessary for the system to work.
We define as ‘good’ behaviors and attitudes that benefit the group, and
‘evil’ as things that give advantage to the individual while damaging the
group. So if I want to steal food
from the store, then I am hurting society by raising prices for everyone while
getting free things for myself. In
our society, this is bad. In
another society, perhaps it is the store that is evil for not sharing the
bounty more freely.
The question is: what is the basic
nature of humans? A baby knows
only its own needs, and toddlers will take what they want without regard for
the rights and needs of others. We
‘socialize’ children to fit our particular expectation of behavior. But this doesn’t mean that the baby or
toddler starts out evil and has to be molded into goodness. Rather they start out as solipsistic
and need to mature by learning to consider the customs of the group. Evil is then defined as those behaviors
that go against the group.
Do these categories apply to other
species? When my cat steals food
off of my plate, is this evil? Can
I hold her to the same standards of behavior as my daughter, who also steals
food off of my plate? In neither
case will I starve because of their actions, but their underlying motivation is
different. My cat sees food, wants
food, takes food. Oh wait, that
sounds like my daughter too! But
in her case, she knows that she has caused more work for me, as I have to go
and find more food. Therefore I
judge her actions as bad, but my cat is just being a cat.
Then is it intent and awareness
that makes an action wrong? Our
justice system will withhold capital punishment if the accused is mentally
retarded. Ignorance of the law is
no excuse, but inability to understand the law is?