Thursday, June 5, 2014

What's Class Got To Do With It? - Readings 12, 13, and 14


Zweig, M. (2004).  What’s Class Got to Do With It? - Reading #12, 5th Edition
The Economist (April 2009). More or Less Equal.  Downloaded from http://www.economist.com/node/13356650/print  (Also Reading #13, 6th Edition)
McNamee, S. J. & Miller Jr, R. K. (2009).  The silver spoon: Inheritance and the staggered start. In The Meritocracy Myth (55-78). Plymouth, UK: Rowman & Littlefield.  (Also Reading #14, 6th Edition)
As Americans, we like to believe that anyone can grow up to be president.  If you work hard and follow the rules, you too can move up in the world.  This series of articles discusses why this is not true.  We don’t like to talk about class in America, preferring to focus on more obvious distinctions such as race and sex, but the fact is that we have different classes as much as the British, just without the cool accents.
Zweig (2004) professes that class should not be defined by income, but rather by the degree of autonomy and power that a group has.  By this definition, the middle class is made up of professionals, small business owners, and business supervisors.  This group is not the bulk of the population, but only about one third of the workers.  They have some degree of control over how they do their job, but they don’t have much power beyond that.  The working class has even less power or authority, doing what they are told without question.  According to Zweig (2004), this was 62% of the workers in 2002.  The opposite extreme, comprising 2% of the labor force, is the capitalist class, the owners and directors of the largest corporations.  It’s not just that they are rich, but that they control the means of making money.
These categories are not clearly delineated, and there are some crossovers at the boundaries, but the point is that it is not the size of the bank account that determines class.  The differences in occupation and power may “lead to differences in incomes, wealth, and lifestyles” (Zweig, 2004, p. 134) but that is not what defines them.  But cause and effect start blurring, and the fact remains that there are advantages to being born into one of the top families.  This is discussed in the second article, The Silver Spoon: Inheritance And The Staggered Start.
McNamee and Miller (2009) claim that America does not have a merit-based system for getting ahead.  If you come from a wealthy, upper class background, then you have a head start before birth.  This ranges from better prenatal care and early childhood benefits ranging from better health and cultural experiences, to access to a social network and ongoing parental support throughout young adulthood.  Children from upper class homes have an easier time getting ahead because they start ahead.  In addition, the upper class maintains exclusivity in order to keep undesirables (read: not born upper class) out.  Again, class is not about money, but money does make a difference in maintaining the class system.
A recent report in The Economist (2009) contemplates the gap between rich and poor.  This gap has been growing rapidly for the past 30 years.  This article, “More or Less Equal”, discusses various factors that may have increased the widening of the income gap.  It also makes an interesting claim that poor stock market returns, falling property prices, and declining corporate profits will help to reduce this gap, mostly because poor folk aren’t affected by these.  The more you have, the greater percentage loss you can bear.  Unfortunately, it doesn’t have any effect on the class system, because the upper class, as stated earlier, isn’t really about the money.
Anyway, I think this is ridiculous!  If someone who is worth 10 million dollars were to lose half of their net worth and only have 5 million dollars, this is a tragic loss of 50%, right?  But someone on the lower end of the spectrum might lose only 10% of their net worth, perhaps dropping from $50K to $45K, and should feel grateful that the income gap is smaller.   Not only will they have more difficulty making ends meet, but public services covered by taxes will also be reduced as the rich pay in less.  So who is really hurt here?  Certainly not the wealthy, who are just a little less wealthy…
These articles remind me of Ruby Paine’s culture of poverty.  Instead, this is a discussion of the culture of wealth.  According to McNamee and Miller (2009), “cultural capital includes, but is not limited to, interpersonal styles and demeanor, manners and etiquette, and vocabulary” (p. 64).  Without giving specifics, it is still clear that breeding will show.  Why is this a more acceptable idea?  How can we generalize that the upper class has a culture of its own without also saying that the lower class does as well?
I know that most people in my circle consider themselves middle class, but based on Zweig’s categories, they are really lower class.  This doesn’t change my view of myself, as I have been poor my whole life, and I don’t anticipate that changing before my retirement at the poverty level.  The difference is that I come from a family of professionals: my father was a doctor and my mother was a nurse.  I have accomplished downward mobility! 
The most interesting thing about these articles is how we (the working class) are bamboozled into accepting the situation because we have misidentified ourselves as middle class and have aspirations to rise even higher.  The Economist puts it clearly: “Perhaps Americans put up with this system because they have unrealistic expectations of their chances of success.”  The myth of the American Dream blinds us to the realities of our place.  Even though these are socially constructed categories – working class, middle class, upper class – they still effect how we identify ourselves.  If we believe that working hard and getting a good education will help us to ‘move up’, however that is defined in our own minds, then we will work hard and get a good education.  This makes the working class more valuable to society because we will be more productive.  If we can do this with the illusion that we are middle class and can move even higher, then will we be happy in our place?  It’s like playing the lottery: I know the odds are against me, but I keep playing because someone has to win eventually.  Maybe it will be me…
As long as we perpetuate the belief in the American Dream and Meritocracy, then we continue to be good workers and do as we are told.  If we acknowledge the truth of the (socially constructed) system, then we will rebel. McNamee and Miller (2009) support this as they say “the only realistic scenario in which the ownership class goes under is one in which America as a whole goes under” (p. 62).  Having seen the misery and suffering in countries around the world as they try to rebel against the status quo, I’m not sure that rebellion is such a good idea.  After all, compared to other countries, even the poor of America have clean water and a free and appropriate education.
Then what should I teach my students?  Is it my responsibility to foment political unrest? Or should I allow them the illusion that they can grow up to be anything they want to be, if only they work hard and get a good education?  I really want to segue into a discussion of the Common Core and the underlying, unspoken message, but I think most people stopped reading this post about one thousand words ago.  I will save that discussion for another day.